A Will or a Trust- Which One Is Bet For You?

Author

Donna Schuyler Law

For more information about the author, click to view their website: Donna Schuyler Law

Posted on

Apr 04, 2024

Book/Edition

Idaho - Boise and the Treasure Valley

Share This

A  Will or Trust: Which is Best for You?

When it comes to deciding whether a will or trust is best for you, it is important to understand your options and which one is most appropriate for your situation.

Will

A testamentary will (simply referred to as a “will”) is a legal document used to transfer an estate to beneficiaries after the death of the “testator” (a male person making the will) or “testatrix” (a female person making the will). Within the will, the testator or testatrix usually names a “personal representative” (same as an “executor”) for the estate. For a will to be valid in Idaho, it must meet specific requirements under Idaho law.

Revocable Living Trusts

A person, during his or her lifetime, may create a “revocable living trust” whereby the grantor (the person making the trust), trustee (the person who has legal authority to manage the trust assets) and beneficiary (the person who makes use of the trust assets) are all the same person.  After the grantor dies, depending on the trust instructions, the trust assets may be distributed outright or held within the trust and distributed over time or upon the happening of a designated event. Revocable living trusts may be appropriate for persons who own real property in more than one state or have a blended family where spouses have children from prior relationships.

Testamentary Trusts

A testamentary trust is a trust within a will. A testamentary trust is created upon the death of a person as specified in his or her will. The testamentary trust holds assets within the trust instead of outright distribution to a beneficiary. A common scenario is when parents create a testamentary trust to hold assets for the support of minor children or for college education for children until they reach a specified age. A testamentary trust can also hold assets for the special needs of a disabled child who receives government benefits.

Does Having a Revocable Living Trust Eliminate Probate?

To avoid the probate process, all assets must be transferred into the name of the revocable living trust. A common misconception is that a list of assets attached to the trust document accomplishes a transfer to the trust. However, the correct way to transfer assets requires an actual change to the title of assets including a home, certificate of deposits, bank accounts and brokerage accounts. Upon death, any assets titled in the name of an individual, not the trust, will be subject to the probate process.

For this reason, when a person creates a revocable living trust, it is best to also create a will, called a pour-over-will, as a safety net to assure that upon death any assets titled in the name of an individual are transferred to the trust and distributed accordingly. In Idaho, generally speaking, the probate process can be quite simple and relatively inexpensive.

A New or Updated Estate Plan

Whether a will or trust is appropriate for you depends on your circumstances. If you already have a will or trust, it should be reviewed periodically to make sure it reflects your current wishes and needs or upon any significant change in your life such as divorce or death of a spouse or beneficiary. Other important estate planning documents include a general durable power of attorney, living will and durable power of attorney for health care.

This article was written by Donna A. Schuyler, Attorney, who practices in the areas of estate planning, probate, trust administration, elder law, and guardianship.

Donna Schuyler Law, PLLC; www.elderlawboise.com; Phone 208-344-1947

Other Articles You May Like

The Surprising Connection Between Health and Estate Planning

You already know that taking care of your health allows you to prolong your life and enhance your quality of life. But have you given serious thought to how your health directly impacts your future? Your legacy? The ones you love the most? What were talking about here is estate planning, and its every bit as important as your physical health. I know, I know, it could sound weird to equate health with estate planning but hear me out. By the end of the article, the connection will be clear.  The Link Between Your Health and Estate PlanningEstate planning often brings to mind wills, trusts, and other legal paperwork, and in fact, thats maybe what you initially thought when you read the title of this article. However, I want to challenge that assumption with this: the documents are merely the byproduct of estate planning. You may be thinking, how are documents the byproduct of estate planning? Heres what I mean.Estate planning is all about ensuring your wishes are honored if you become incapacitated so you can live and die with dignity. Its also about ensuring that the people you love most will know you loved them, that theyre cared for when youre gone in a way you cared for them while you lived, and that youve removed all the pain, potential conflict and expense they will have to endure if you have no plan in place. Estate planning supports your loved ones to grieve in peace rather than face a long, expensive court process or confusion regarding how to find your assets or understand what to do when you are gone. Estate planning is also about leaving a legacy. Contrary to what you may be thinking - that legacy is not only related to money and reserved for the wealthy and philanthropic - legacy is about the mark you make on those you hold most dear. Its about defining your humanity and what you stood for. Putting your affairs in order now so your loved ones dont have to deal with a mess later is a legacy, too. Making it clear that you loved your family is a legacy. What about health? How does your health connect with estate planning?Your health plays a significant role in shaping your preparations for the future in general, and how you structure your estate plan in particular. I want to first say that while health can refer to mental health, emotional health and spiritual health, and all are important, well focus on physical health here. So lets take a look at the direct link between your physical health and estate planning. Youll come to see that by prioritizing your physical health, you can not only enjoy life with more ease, but also avoid complications in your estate planning. Longevity and Retirement Savings. Your physical health has a direct impact on your lifespan, which in turn affects how long your retirement savings need to last. If you maintain good physical health, youre likely to live longer (yay!) and will need a more extensive plan regarding your assets, for your longer life.Healthcare Decisions. Consider the potential need for long-term care. Alzheimer's or dementia could require long-term care solutions that you may or may not choose. In your estate plan, its crucial to not only make sure youre financially covered for these possibilities, but to also ensure youve made it clear how you want to be cared for, if you cannot make decisions for yourself. There comes a point in time at which its too late for you to make your wishes known and given that you are reading this now is the time to document what you would choose, if you could not choose.This is why you need a healthcare power of attorney, or a living will in your plan. These are documents that designate the person (or people) you choose to make medical decisions on your behalf if youre unable to do so. Your designated healthcare agent (or agents) will not only ensure that your healthcare preferences are respected but will also align your medical treatment with your personal wishes. Without these documents in place, a judge (i.e., a complete stranger) could appoint someone to act on your behalf. Maybe even someone you dont trust or wouldnt want making decisions for you. Or, in a worst-case scenario, a judge could even appoint a professional conservator who could drain your estate financially.Disability and Its Impact. Poor health can sometimes lead to disability, affecting your ability to manage your own affairs. Including a disability clause in your estate plan ensures that your assets are managed according to your wishes, even if youre not able to oversee them personally. A revocable living trust can be particularly useful here, as it allows your chosen person or entity to manage your affairs without the need for court intervention. Again, without a plan in place, a judge will make decisions for you, and those decisions may not be what you want.Having gone through the potential consequences of not prioritizing your physical health and its direct link to your estate planning, lets turn to practical steps you can take now to make sure you and your family dont have to experience any negative consequences. Practical Steps to Integrate Health and Estate PlanningUnless youre already incapacitated and cant make decisions for yourself, know that its not too late to take action. Its not too early, either. Death and incapacity dont discriminate based on age. When you face that fact, and then plan accordingly, you can live life with more ease, more joy, and less stress. Truly.So, if you havent planned for the future, here are some practical steps you can take now:Schedule Regular Check-Ups. It may seem obvious, but regular medical examinations are vital. They not only help in detecting illnesses early but also provide a clear picture of your health, which, as weve discussed above, is crucial for accurate estate planning. If you discover a new health condition, you can plan accordingly when youve caught it in time. If not, it could be too late to get your plan in place.Update Your Estate Plan Regularly: As your health changes, so should your estate plan. Make it a habit to review and update your plan on a regular basis or whenever there is a significant change in your health. As an Estate Planning Attorney, I can not only help you get your initial plan in place, but with a unique process I use called Life & Legacy Planning, I will always include a free review of your plan at least every three years. This ensures your plan works because it will be updated as your health, life and assets change over time. Without updates, your plan will fail, sending your family to court and increasing the probability of conflict. Discuss Your Plans Openly: Talk with your family about your healthcare wishes and how they relate to your estate plan. Taking this courageous, and maybe uncomfortable, step, makes a big difference when it comes to decreasing the likelihood of conflict in your family. Make sure to discuss your preferences for end-of-life care, which can create conflict in your family if you havent clarified your wishes. Consult A Professional Who Has Your Best Interests in Mind: I approach estate planning from a place of heart, always keeping your best interests, and by extension, your loved ones best interests, in mind. I not only help you to get your plan in place, but also help you keep your family out of court and conflict, so your legacy is one of love and care. I can also help you navigate difficult discussions with your family about your wishes, so you can feel confident knowing youve done all you can to preserve the family bonds. How We Support You and Your Loved OnesAs an Estate Planning Law Firm, we recognize the integral connection between your physical health and your estate planning needs. Our commitment goes beyond mere legal documentation; we aim to ensure your life's work and values are preserved with dignity and clarity. By understanding the specific challenges and opportunities that arise from your health, we tailor estate plans that not only protect your assets but also your well-being and your family's future. Contact Entrusted Legacy Law at 412-347-1731 or click here to schedule a complimentary 15-Minute call.

Family Involvement in Elder Law

As an estate planning and elder law attorney, I have seen a little bit of everything over the past 20 years. I am a big believer in having loved ones be part of the estate planning process to ensure that everybody is on the same page. Unfortunately, there are a few unscrupulous individuals whose objectives are to take advantage of their parents in one way or another. This does not change my opinion that estate planning and elder law are a team sport and that they should always include the financial advisor, the accountant, as well as the family. However, it is imperative that the professionals who are working with the individual stay vigilant and watch for signs of exploitation or abuse. Although it can often be very subtle, professionals usually have the skills and the tools to be able to see through it and bring attention to it. In an extreme case, a professional will contact the Area Agency on Aging and notify the Adult Protective Services division. They have authority under the Adult Protective Services Act to protect individuals in or around our community. However, that is definitely the exception to the rule, and in most cases, it is enough to have the family members leave the room and talk to the client alone to determine whether or not they are being unduly influenced or if they are speaking freely on their own. Most elderly individuals dont always realize what is occurring and therefore are not trying to hide it. They dont realize what is going on, so a trained professional can often ask the right questions to determine if something is not right. In the vast majority of cases, I do think that having family involvement in the elder law process is beneficial to everyone involved.

How Estate Planning Needs Change Throughout Your Life

Welcome to Legal Briefs, every month we will cover a topic of interest to our clients in one of our practice areas. First up Whats the big deal? Does everyone really need estate planning? The short answer is yes. Lets address why at a few key life stages.Young AdultsOnce you turn 18 years of age, you need a will and medical and financial powers of attorney (POA). Why? These documents allow for someone you trust to step in and help when needed. Emergencies and accidents happen. If you get sick or injured, a medical power of attorney can help with HIPAA, ensuring your trusted health care agent makes decisions with doctors and medical staff. Similarly, if you are unable to make financial decisions, a financial power of attorney names someone you trust to act on your behalf. A will names beneficiaries for assets and personal property and establishes your personal representative, who makes decisions regarding your estate if you pass away. At Stone Law we take the time to meet with you and help you ensure these basic estate planning building blocks meet your needs and wishes.Young Families  As you start a family its important to have a will naming guardians for minor children. This allows you to determine who will care for your children, instead of leaving this crucial decision up to a court or judge. As with any stage in life, its still wise to have medical and financial powers of attorney so decision making is easier if you are unable to act for yourself. Your spouse or significant other does not automatically have a right to makedecisions for you. Medical and financial powers of attorney are necessary to make sure the right people have authority to act on your behalf when needed. Stone Laws Young Family Plan is designed to fit easily into the chaos and busyness of your life at this stage.Older Families and AdultsAs you grow older your needs change. Estate planning should be updated every few years. As children grow, a more comprehensive estate plan can help protect your legacy for your adult children. Trusts change the way your assets and estate planning work. They allow flexibility across state lines, protection for blended families, and additional privacy. Depending on laws when your trust is signed, trusts can also plan for tax issues and concerns. Your situation is unique to you, at Stone Law we take the time to meet with you, working together to determine what kinds of planning best meet your needs and circumstances.Does it feel like theres no good time to sit down and discuss who you want in these roles when busy with work, parenting and life? You are not alone. Instead of avoiding a difficult conversation, give Stone Law a call at 877-897-6591 today. Allow us to work with you, whatever stage you are in, ensuring the process fits your busy life. Start your path to peace of mind today.

Local Services By This Author

Donna Schuyler Law PLLC

Medicare/Medicaid/Insurance PO Box 2617, Boise, Idaho, 83701

With over 25 years of experience as an elder advocate, Attorney Donna Schuyler practices in the areas of elder law, estate planning, guardianship, conservatorship and probate.Her lifes work is to provide protection for this vulnerable population and help elders achieve a high quality of life while preserving dignity and respect.Donna is a member of the Idaho State Bar Taxation, Probate and Trust Law Section, a member of the Idaho State Bar Professionalism and Ethics Section, past president and current member of the Treasure Valley Estate Planning Council and board member of Trust and Estate Professionals of Idaho. She has authored numerous articles on elder issues and lectures nationwide on estate planning and elder matters.

Donna Schuyler Law PLLC

Conservatorship PO Box 2617, Boise, Idaho, 83701

With over 25 years of experience as an elder advocate, Attorney Donna Schuyler practices in the areas of elder law, estate planning, guardianship, conservatorship and probate.Her lifes work is to provide protection for this vulnerable population and help elders achieve a high quality of life while preserving dignity and respect.Donna is a member of the Idaho State Bar Taxation, Probate and Trust Law Section, a member of the Idaho State Bar Professionalism and Ethics Section, past president and current member of the Treasure Valley Estate Planning Council and board member of Trust and Estate Professionals of Idaho. She has authored numerous articles on elder issues and lectures nationwide on estate planning and elder matters.

Donna Schuyler Law PLLC

Elder Law PO Box 2617, Boise, Idaho, 83701

With over 25 years of experience as an elder advocate, Attorney Donna Schuyler practices in the areas of elder law, estate planning, guardianship, conservatorship and probate.Her lifes work is to provide protection for this vulnerable population and help elders achieve a high quality of life while preserving dignity and respect.Donna is a member of the Idaho State Bar Taxation, Probate and Trust Law Section, a member of the Idaho State Bar Professionalism and Ethics Section, past president and current member of the Treasure Valley Estate Planning Council and board member of Trust and Estate Professionals of Idaho. She has authored numerous articles on elder issues and lectures nationwide on estate planning and elder matters.