A Will or a Trust- Which One Is Bet For You?

Author

Donna Schuyler Law

For more information about the author, click to view their website: Donna Schuyler Law

Posted on

Apr 04, 2024

Book/Edition

Idaho - Boise and the Treasure Valley

Share This

A  Will or Trust: Which is Best for You?

When it comes to deciding whether a will or trust is best for you, it is important to understand your options and which one is most appropriate for your situation.

Will

A testamentary will (simply referred to as a “will”) is a legal document used to transfer an estate to beneficiaries after the death of the “testator” (a male person making the will) or “testatrix” (a female person making the will). Within the will, the testator or testatrix usually names a “personal representative” (same as an “executor”) for the estate. For a will to be valid in Idaho, it must meet specific requirements under Idaho law.

Revocable Living Trusts

A person, during his or her lifetime, may create a “revocable living trust” whereby the grantor (the person making the trust), trustee (the person who has legal authority to manage the trust assets) and beneficiary (the person who makes use of the trust assets) are all the same person.  After the grantor dies, depending on the trust instructions, the trust assets may be distributed outright or held within the trust and distributed over time or upon the happening of a designated event. Revocable living trusts may be appropriate for persons who own real property in more than one state or have a blended family where spouses have children from prior relationships.

Testamentary Trusts

A testamentary trust is a trust within a will. A testamentary trust is created upon the death of a person as specified in his or her will. The testamentary trust holds assets within the trust instead of outright distribution to a beneficiary. A common scenario is when parents create a testamentary trust to hold assets for the support of minor children or for college education for children until they reach a specified age. A testamentary trust can also hold assets for the special needs of a disabled child who receives government benefits.

Does Having a Revocable Living Trust Eliminate Probate?

To avoid the probate process, all assets must be transferred into the name of the revocable living trust. A common misconception is that a list of assets attached to the trust document accomplishes a transfer to the trust. However, the correct way to transfer assets requires an actual change to the title of assets including a home, certificate of deposits, bank accounts and brokerage accounts. Upon death, any assets titled in the name of an individual, not the trust, will be subject to the probate process.

For this reason, when a person creates a revocable living trust, it is best to also create a will, called a pour-over-will, as a safety net to assure that upon death any assets titled in the name of an individual are transferred to the trust and distributed accordingly. In Idaho, generally speaking, the probate process can be quite simple and relatively inexpensive.

A New or Updated Estate Plan

Whether a will or trust is appropriate for you depends on your circumstances. If you already have a will or trust, it should be reviewed periodically to make sure it reflects your current wishes and needs or upon any significant change in your life such as divorce or death of a spouse or beneficiary. Other important estate planning documents include a general durable power of attorney, living will and durable power of attorney for health care.

This article was written by Donna A. Schuyler, Attorney, who practices in the areas of estate planning, probate, trust administration, elder law, and guardianship.

Donna Schuyler Law, PLLC; www.elderlawboise.com; Phone 208-344-1947

Other Articles You May Like

Nurturing Harmony in Caregiving: Open Communication and Conflict Prevention

Caring for aging parents involves crucial decisions regarding who will provide the necessary care and in what setting. However, these decisions can often give rise to conflicts among family members, particularly when one sibling assumes the role of primary caregiver. Through our work with clients and families, we frequently encounter these stressful and emotionally charged situations, creating a perfect storm for family disputes and distress.Reflecting on recent consultations with families, it becomes apparent that a key factor contributing to conflicts is the failure of aging parents to openly express their wishes and expectations regarding potential scenarios. When parents do not communicate their desires early and consistently, adult children are left to speculate about their parents preferences, leading to differences of opinion and sibling conflicts. To prevent such difficulties, we urge you to initiate conversations with your adult children about what if scenarios and discuss your wishes and preferences openly. This proactive effort can serve as your conflict prevention plan, saving you and your loved ones from engaging in conflict resolution in the future.In situations where a family member becomes a paid caregiver, it is essential to establish a formal caregiver agreement. This agreement serves multiple purposes, including clarifying the financial aspects of the care being provided. By having a caregiver agreement in place, you can prevent misunderstandings and promote a harmonious caregiving environment within your family. It ensures that everyone is on the same page and understands the expectations and parameters involved.Above all, open and honest communication is the key to fostering understanding and preventing conflicts among family members. We strongly recommend engaging in conversations early and frequently to address concerns, preferences, and potential challenges that may arise in caregiving situations. By doing so, you can promote a supportive and respectful environment where everyones needs are acknowledged and considered.At Bellomo & Associates, we believe in nurturing harmony within families facing caregiving challenges. Our experienced team is dedicated to providing comprehensive estate planning and elder law services that cater to your unique circumstances. Start the conversation with your adult children today, discussing your wishes, expectations, and potential what if scenarios. Visit our website to learn more about how we can support you and register for our free educational workshop. Let us help you pave the way for peaceful resolutions and a smoother caregiving journey.

Dealing with Deed Spam Mail

Have you recently purchased a home or made any changes to your propertys deed? Have you received an unexpected letter offering a copy of your deed for a fee? If so, youve likely encountered spam mail.Theres a company known as Land Solutions based in California that sends out Recorder of Deed Notices to individuals with newly recorded deeds. These notices claim that you can obtain a copy of your deed for a service fee of $109.00. Since the transfer of a deed is a matter of public record, they can easily access your name, address, and property information. While what theyre doing may not be a scam, we prefer to refer to it as spam. The truth is, the party responsible for transferring the deed, or even your local recorder of deeds, can provide you with a copy for a small fee or sometimes even for free. Theres no need to pay a separate company for this service.At Bellomo & Associates, many of our clients have received this type of letter, and we are delighted that they reached out to us before paying an unnecessary fee for a document we already possess on their behalf.When you receive such correspondence after making any changes, its crucial to research the company that sent it, reach out to the parties you were working with, and carefully read the fine print. In the case of these specific notices, the fine print typically states that it is not a bill but a solicitation, and you are not legally obligated to pay the amount requested.Together, we can minimize the impact of spam by working collectively and staying informed.  

Family Conflicts Over Caregiving

As our parents age, the primary questions adult children face are (1) who is going to provide needed care, and (2) in what setting will mom or dad receive the needed care. Coming to such decisions does not always mean smooth sailing moving forward. Family members often view care issues very differently and conflicts can be further complicated when one of the siblings is the primary caregiver. Our team members find such conflicts to be quite common in their work with our clients and families. The situations are stressful and charged with emotion, worry, and exhaustionthe perfect storm for conflict and family duress.As I reflect on the meetings and consultations I have had with some of these families recently, I suspect that part of the problem is the fact that the aging parents failed to verbalizeearly and oftentheir wishes and desires related to the what if scenarios. Because their folks did not talk openly about their wishes and expectations, the adult children are often forced to guess what Mom and Dad would have wantedanother perfect storm for differences of opinion and sibling conflicts.If you have not already done so, commit to conversing with your adult children about the what ifs. Let them know your wishes and preferences. Consider the effort to be your conflict prevention plan, so that down the road, you and yours wont have to engage in conflict resolution. And be sure to have a formal caregiver agreement drafted if a family member becomes the paid caregiver. It is an important tool for many reasons, including clarifying the financial parameters of the care being provided. Doing so will prevent misunderstandings between those you love most. Open, honest communication is always the key, and we recommend it early and often in these situations.

Local Services By This Author

Donna Schuyler Law

Elder Abuse Prevention 750 Warm Springs Ave Ste C, Boise, Idaho, 83701

With over 25 years of experience as an elder advocate, Attorney Donna Schuyler practices in the areas of elder law, estate planning, guardianship, conservatorship and probate.Her lifes work is to provide protection for this vulnerable population and help elders achieve a high quality of life while preserving dignity and respect.Donna is a member of the Idaho State Bar Taxation, Probate and Trust Law Section, a member of the Idaho State Bar Professionalism and Ethics Section, past president and current member of the Treasure Valley Estate Planning Council and board member of Trust and Estate Professionals of Idaho. She has authored numerous articles on elder issues and lectures nationwide on estate planning and elder matters.

Donna Schuyler Law

Elder Law 750 Warm Springs Ave Ste C, Boise, Idaho, 83701

With over 25 years of experience as an elder advocate, Attorney Donna Schuyler practices in the areas of elder law, estate planning, guardianship, conservatorship and probate.Her lifes work is to provide protection for this vulnerable population and help elders achieve a high quality of life while preserving dignity and respect.Donna is a member of the Idaho State Bar Taxation, Probate and Trust Law Section, a member of the Idaho State Bar Professionalism and Ethics Section, past president and current member of the Treasure Valley Estate Planning Council and board member of Trust and Estate Professionals of Idaho. She has authored numerous articles on elder issues and lectures nationwide on estate planning and elder matters.

Donna Schuyler Law

Conservatorship 750 Warm Springs Ave Ste C, Boise, Idaho, 83701

With over 25 years of experience as an elder advocate, Attorney Donna Schuyler practices in the areas of elder law, estate planning, guardianship, conservatorship and probate.Her lifes work is to provide protection for this vulnerable population and help elders achieve a high quality of life while preserving dignity and respect.Donna is a member of the Idaho State Bar Taxation, Probate and Trust Law Section, a member of the Idaho State Bar Professionalism and Ethics Section, past president and current member of the Treasure Valley Estate Planning Council and board member of Trust and Estate Professionals of Idaho. She has authored numerous articles on elder issues and lectures nationwide on estate planning and elder matters.