How to Analyze Climate Scenarios for Your Portfolio

Author

Morgan Stanley Wealth Management

For more information about the author, click to view their website: Morgan Stanley

Posted on

Jan 09, 2024

Book/Edition

Florida - Southwest

Share This

Using climate scenario analysis offers investors a methodical approach to understand the portfolio impacts of different environmental and economic outcomes.

  • Estimating the long-term effects of climate change on portfolios is inherently difficult, but climate scenario analysis can be a useful tool for investors.
  • Using specialized computer models, climate scenario analysis assesses the potential impact of future events to help investors understand related risks and opportunities.
  • Institutional investors can use this process to quantify the potential impacts of climate change on their portfolios at the individual company, sector, market and global levels.

Climate change is widely considered to be one of the most significant global risks to society and economies. However, many institutional investors find it difficult to quantitatively assess what financial impact climate change could have on their portfolios. 

 

Climate scenario analysis offers a methodical way forward, according to the Morgan Stanley Institute for Sustainable Investing’s new report, “Integrating Climate Scenario Analysis into the Investment Process.” With the right data and models, institutional investors can better quantify the economic effects of climate change in the same way that they currently analyze the potential impact of market signals and economic indicators.

 

Investors have shown interest in using this nascent method to map climate-related uncertainties. An Institute for Sustainable Investing survey found that while more than half of asset owners want asset managers to conduct climate scenario analysis, less than one-third provide it. At the same time, investors are also increasingly expected to conduct climate scenario analysis to meet disclosure expectations, such as the Taskforce on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), and even certain regulatory requirements.

 

What Is Climate Scenario Analysis?

At present, the impact of climate change on portfolios is difficult to measure and predict accurately. The understanding of climate science itself is constantly evolving in response to new data, and investment horizons are typically much shorter than climate impact timescales. As a result, it can be challenging to relate non- financial factors such as greenhouse gas emissions directly to financial outcomes.

 

Using specialized computer models, climate scenario analysis assesses the impact of future events, to help investors understand related risks and opportunities. Quantitative climate scenarios are the best way to explore the connections between environmental factors (e.g., greenhouse gas emissions) and financial factors (e.g., gross domestic product, carbon prices and energy prices).

 

Consider two possible climate futures:

 

  • Temperatures increase by 1.5°C or well below 2°C above preindustrial levels, resulting in greater transition risks (financial or reputational) to businesses as they decarbonize; or 

  • Temperatures increase by 3°C or more from preindustrial levels, resulting in greater physical risks such as sea-level rise, catastrophic weather events and loss of arable land. 

 
Each of these scenarios would yield different political, social, technological and environmental considerations and outcomes. As a result, the global economy and market conditions in each scenario would differ. For climate scenario analysis in portfolios to be effective, investors must define a reasonable range of scenarios, supported by data, models and reliable practices, with the aim of assessing the impact on portfolios. 

 

4 Steps for Climate Scenario Analysis

Climate scenario analysis can be categorized into four main stages:

 

  1. Set the question. First, investors need to define what question they want to explore. This will inform how the scenarios are constructed, which variables need to be tested or held constant, and the required outputs. 

     

  2. Build the scenarios. Investors can either choose pre-defined scenarios provided by organizations such as the Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS) or build their own custom scenarios, which offer more nuance and control but are more complex and require a greater understanding of climate science. 

     

  3. Conduct analysis. Mathematical computer models—usually Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs)—draw the relationship between greenhouse gas emissions and social and economic factors. If an investor uses scenarios from organizations like NGFS, then this analysis will already have been completed; for custom scenarios, investors would run this analysis themselves with input from experts who understand how IAMs work. 

     

  4. Use outputs. Outputs can be used directly to inform portfolio risk analysis or bottom-up company analysis. Potential outputs could include prices for energy, carbon and other commodities, as well as imports/exports, emissions, supply/demand volumes and land use.

 
The resulting outputs can then be used to analyze portfolio impacts for overall climate change risks. This can take the form of bottom-up company analysis or top-down macroeconomic analysis, generating estimates on factors such as bond yields, inflation or index prices.

 

At each stage, investors may need to find a balance between competing priorities. Most notably, limited resources may constrain the level of detail that can be built in. Some of the challenges involved in using climate scenario modelling based on constantly evolving understandings of climate science cannot yet be resolved, and so the impact of physical risks, such as flooding, may be structurally understated in models. However, most challenges can be managed. 

 

Case Study: Carbon Capture and Pricing Scenarios

Morgan Stanley applied its in-house climate scenario capabilities to a case study that examines two scenarios related to the availability of carbon capture and storage (CCS), an emerging technology used to remove CO2 before, during or after the combustion of fossil fuels or biomass. The International Energy Agency (IEA)1 forecasts that meeting global net-zero targets requires a significant contribution from innovative technologies such as CCS, which is widely used in climate scenario analysis, but has yet to live up to its promise because of high costs and challenges with scale. 

 

We considered two scenarios: CCS technologies being able to remove either 23 or 15 gigatons of carbon from the atmosphere by 2050, with other variables such as population, GDP and government policy on emissions held constant. Analyzing these paths shows different outcomes for CO2 emissions, carbon pricing, primary energy mix and electricity costs. Taking the carbon price as an example, when CCS technologies can sequester 23 gigatons of carbon, the 2050 carbon price is approximately $750 per ton of CO2. By contrast, when CCS can only remove 15 gigatons, the carbon price shoots up to approximately $1,100 per ton of CO2, reflecting higher costs of CCS in the lower volume scenario.  

 

This analysis could inform a range of potential portfolio outcomes, including long-term fossil fuel demand, the impact on earnings for companies in energy and beyond, energy consumption and household spending.

 

Quantifying Climate Impacts on Portfolios Despite Complexity

While climate change scenario analysis is a relatively new practice, it echoes how investors already assess the global markets and economy. Understandably, a constant stream of new climate change findings, data, policies, technologies and dynamics make risk assessment seem daunting. But climate scenario analysis can serve as a useful tool for institutional investors who want a methodical approach to understanding the potential impacts of climate change in their portfolios.

Other Articles You May Like

Financing Senior Care & Assisted Living

PERSONAL FUNDS Utilizing personal funds to pay for a move to a Senior Living Community is an uncomplicated option for some people. Whether it be through savings, liquidating certain assets, or drawing upon investment income, this strategy provides seniors with a payment method that they have the most direct control over. Working with a financial advisor to plan for this is often beneficial. In addition, many Senior Living Communities have special team members who are experienced in financial matters and can offer assistance as well. SOCIAL SECURITY & MEDICARE   Social Security payments can be used to help pay for the costs of living in a Senior Community. However, the amount it would cover will depend on the recipients monthly benefit.  According to U.S. News and World Report, the current average benefit paid is $1,657 each month. It is important to understand that while Medicare does not cover the actual costs of living in an Independent Living, Assisted Living or Memory Care Community, it does help pay for other critical needs, such as prescriptions, doctor visits, medical equipment and  other health care related expenses. LONG TERM CARE INSURANCE & LIFE INSURANCE Long Term Care insurance (LTC) is a special type of policy that helps pay the expenses of home care or a Senior Living Community. The amount of benefit available from a LTC policy can vary by such factors as the amount of the monthly payment, as well as the duration of the benefit.  Some life insurance policies can be cashed in for a lump sum payment while the insured is still living under what is known as a Life Settlement arrangement. Policy holders should review their life insurance contracts to see if this feature is available to them.    VETERANS BENEFITS If you or a loved one served in the military, the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) has programs that can help pay for certain Senior Living services. While these dont pay for direct housing expenses, the VAs Aid and Attendance benefit is available to veterans that meet certain income requirements and also have difficulty performing activities of daily living (ADLs), such as dressing, eating, bathing, using the restroom, or moving about.  REAL ESTATE ASSETS If the person thinking about moving into a Senior Community is a homeowner, their house can be a good revenue source. Selling the home, renting it out, or arranging for a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) are all ways to help pay for living expenses at the new residence. If you have any questions, call us today at 402-819-0669.

Why Use an SRES when Selling your Home?

Is it time to sell your home? Maybe youre ready to retire, downsize or a major event has made it necessary to move to a senior community.  No matter what the reason a Seniors Real Estate Specialist (SRES) has unique training to help guide you through the process and find whats right for you.  Selling a home can be a difficult decision and is an emotional time for most.  An SRES understands the issues facing older adults and their families.  They will patiently support and help you through each step by taking the time needed to make everyone feel comfortable through the complex process. An SRES has built a network of professionals who are also focused on serving older adults.  Theyve identified helpful experts in all areas, from financial and tax specialists to right-sizing and moving help, along with trusted contractors to prepare the home. Their ties throughout the 55+ community can even help you with finding the right active adult community or other more needs specific senior community.  Your SRES is looking out for your best interests throughout all aspects of your transition, not just the sale of your home.  Theyve invested time in becoming an SRES because they enjoy working with clients in your situation and truly care about helping others. You can count on your SRES to guide you by making the entire process less stressful and more successful.  Editors Note: This article was written by Alyce Chermack, Realtor & SRES. Alyce is a Seniors Real Estate Specialist with The Platinum Group, REALTORS and can be reached at 303-475-2792 or via email at Alyce@PlatinumHomeSales.com

5 Technology Investing Trends for 2023

                                             Companies and investors are watching five technology trends around the exchange of data in industrials, insurance, healthcare, digital infrastructure and resource planning.A number of industries need technology solutions that facilitate the widespread exchange of data, creating opportunities for public and private investing and M&A.Industrial companies are investing in technology that manages, digitalizes and automates their physical assets.Technology developments in insurance may lead to the next fintech.Healthcare providers are seeking solutions that improve productivity and patient outcomes.Digital infrastructure will evolve to support massive and growing data needs.Artificial intelligence, cloud and security are trends to watch in enterprise resource planning and human resources. Interoperabilitysoftware platforms ability to communicate and share data and informationis the next frontier for technology innovation. Technology companies are increasing their customer bases with products that connect disparate data for consumers, creating a seamless experience. At Morgan Stanleys recent Technology, Media and Telecom (TMT) Conference in Barcelona, the firms investment bankers discussed five key themes in this space that point to investment opportunities. Were in the very early innings of a multi-decade development in data, analytics capabilities and software within specific industries, said Lauren Ares, a Morgan Stanley banker specializing in B2B information services and data analytics. Businesses are vying to become top-three market leaders in the sectors where they are focused, and investors are looking where to place their bets.1Industrial Companies: Early Stages of Digital ConnectivityIndustrial companies in the automotive, energy and construction sectors are just starting to use systems that offer help managing physical assets and that connect disparate parts of value chains. There are numerous opportunities for industrials to increase efficiency with such solutions. For an energy company, for example, helpful connectivity solutions might offer an overview of all physical assets as well as features such as pipeline safety notifications that automatically assign workers to investigate and address issues, said Bjoern Crombach, a Morgan Stanley banker who specializes in industrial software. For a car manufacturer, technologies might automate reordering paint once supply runs low to help the company keep up production. Industrial companies are demanding software that helps manage their different stages of day-to-day business, Crombach said. Private companies are offering a number of promising solutions, and thus attracting the attention of large public companies interested in acquisitions, he said.2Insurtech: The Next Fintech?Compared to industrials, technology is in further stages of development for the insurance sector (known as insurtech) as proliferation and use of software applications in the industry has been growing for five years, Ares said. A significant number of businesses have emerged in insurtech with meaningful revenue growth and attractive profitability, he said. Investors are interested in whether insurtech could be the next fintech. Insurtech technology spans data analysis, Internet of Things (IoT)i.e., physical devicesand AI, and it aims to facilitate cost savings and efficiencies in processing claims, evaluating risks and underwriting policies. With mainstream adoption of open banking and payments apps in the last decade, fintech has become the poster child proving the value of networks that connect and manage various sources and forms of data, an incredibly sticky proposition for any industry, Ares said. Companies offering tailored technology solutions in verticals such as insurance are betting that apps and online platforms can catch on, similar to how they did in consumer banking and financial services.3Healthcare Technology for the Continuum of CareHealthcare is an industry lagging behind in its adoption of technology, so opportunities abound to improve patient outcomes and accessibility to healthcare amid caregiver labor shortages and the rising cost of care in Europe and the U.S. One method is complete data sharing between patients doctors and care locations (i.e. clinics and labs): Data-centric healthcare requires technology embedded throughout the continuum of care, said Marie-Gabrielle Bui, a Morgan Stanley banker who specializes in healthcare technology. A patients doctors and patients themselves should be able to easily access secure data that is privacy-compliant across care locations. Another lever is to move chronic patients from emergency care, which is extremely expensive, to preventative care, which is more affordable, Bui said. One example is healthcare technology that helps diabetic patients by continuously monitoring their glucose levels, warning them when levels are too high and scheduling doctors appointments and follow-up when necessary. Other avenues include artificial intelligence (AI)-backed symptom checkers and gamified apps for patient engagement or chatbots providing tools for psychological support, such as cognitive behavioral therapy. Given wide demand for healthcare technology, companies are looking to acquire businesses that offer healthcare software or digital health tools because M&Aeven across country bordersmay cost less than fully developing solutions in-house, Bui said. In particular, European companies are interested in acquisitions to capture more geographic market share, despite different local regulations.4Trends in Digital InfrastructureData consumption by businesses and consumers is continuing to grow exponentially, driving demand for all types of digital infrastructurenotably fiber, data centers and mobile towers. In recent years, this has also driven high levels of M&A activity and valuations, with lower-cost capital providers becoming increasingly comfortable with future growth prospects. Nevertheless, the current macroeconomic environment is a test for the asset class, said Max Thiele, a Morgan Stanley banker who specializes in digital infrastructure: While the investment case for digital infrastructure continues to be very strong and demand for quality assets is high, companies and investors are carefully scrutinizing the impact of inflation, power prices and the risk of recession, including if and how certain cost drivers can be passed through to customers. In addition, market participants are searching for the next adjacent infrastructure growth and capital deployment opportunities, Thiele said. This includes investments in tier 2 cities and markets, infrastructure deployments in preparation of new exciting use cases, such as edge computing, and also asset classes that have historically not been considered classic infrastructure but have proven highly predictable and economically resilient.5Cloud and AI for Resource Planning and HRCompanies across industries are looking to technology to streamline internal functions such as enterprise resource planning (ERP) and human resources (HR), said Leila Harestani, a Morgan Stanley banker who specializes in ERP and HR technology. In ERP, one of the biggest trends is cloud for deployment, in which software is hosted on vendors servers and accessed through a web browser, generally at a lower cost than the alternative on-premises software, which is installed locally on a companys computers or servers. As cloud-based ERP proliferates, more small- and medium-sized businesses may adopt these solutions, but vendors will have to prove they have prepared for security risks, such as who can access sensitive data and potential data theft by malicious actors, Harestani said. Another important theme is the use of AI to identify and learn from data patterns, which offers widespread applications for forecasting and modelling, supply chain tracking and customer service. In HR, AI is useful for recruiting, onboarding and employee engagement, and companies are also investigating how the blockchain could enable better data security through encryption, according to Harestani. Emerging private companies are the frontrunners offering these ERP and HR capabilities, and that has led to M&A interest from bigger companies, Harestani said. The more innovative and advanced technology solutions are coming from start-ups, and existing players in the marketlarger companies and private equity firmsmay look to acquire them.Looking AheadEmerging technology in industrials, insurance, healthcare, digital infrastructure and enterprise resource planning is enabling the exchange of data across value chains, and investors are monitoring companies that help connect data across disparate sources in specific sectors. Given demand for these solutions, big companies and private equity firms are on the hunt for acquisitions to increase their market share within industry verticals. Next

Local Services By This Author

Morgan Stanley Wealth Management

Financial Advisor 8889 Pelican Bay Boulevard, Naples, Florida, 34108

At Morgan Stanley, we advise, originate, trade, manage and distribute capital for people, governments and institutions, always with a standard of excellence and guided by our core values.Morgan Stanley is dedicated to providing first-class service to our clients, in a way that reflects our commitment to creating a more sustainable future and fostering stronger communities around the world. In each line of business, we strive to demonstrate our belief in the power of transformative thinking, innovative strategies and leading-edge solutionsand in the ability of capital to work for the benefit of all society.