How to Analyze Climate Scenarios for Your Portfolio

Author

Morgan Stanley Wealth Management

For more information about the author, click to view their website: Morgan Stanley

Posted on

Jan 09, 2024

Book/Edition

Florida - Southwest

Share This

Using climate scenario analysis offers investors a methodical approach to understand the portfolio impacts of different environmental and economic outcomes.

  • Estimating the long-term effects of climate change on portfolios is inherently difficult, but climate scenario analysis can be a useful tool for investors.
  • Using specialized computer models, climate scenario analysis assesses the potential impact of future events to help investors understand related risks and opportunities.
  • Institutional investors can use this process to quantify the potential impacts of climate change on their portfolios at the individual company, sector, market and global levels.

Climate change is widely considered to be one of the most significant global risks to society and economies. However, many institutional investors find it difficult to quantitatively assess what financial impact climate change could have on their portfolios. 

 

Climate scenario analysis offers a methodical way forward, according to the Morgan Stanley Institute for Sustainable Investing’s new report, “Integrating Climate Scenario Analysis into the Investment Process.” With the right data and models, institutional investors can better quantify the economic effects of climate change in the same way that they currently analyze the potential impact of market signals and economic indicators.

 

Investors have shown interest in using this nascent method to map climate-related uncertainties. An Institute for Sustainable Investing survey found that while more than half of asset owners want asset managers to conduct climate scenario analysis, less than one-third provide it. At the same time, investors are also increasingly expected to conduct climate scenario analysis to meet disclosure expectations, such as the Taskforce on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), and even certain regulatory requirements.

 

What Is Climate Scenario Analysis?

At present, the impact of climate change on portfolios is difficult to measure and predict accurately. The understanding of climate science itself is constantly evolving in response to new data, and investment horizons are typically much shorter than climate impact timescales. As a result, it can be challenging to relate non- financial factors such as greenhouse gas emissions directly to financial outcomes.

 

Using specialized computer models, climate scenario analysis assesses the impact of future events, to help investors understand related risks and opportunities. Quantitative climate scenarios are the best way to explore the connections between environmental factors (e.g., greenhouse gas emissions) and financial factors (e.g., gross domestic product, carbon prices and energy prices).

 

Consider two possible climate futures:

 

  • Temperatures increase by 1.5°C or well below 2°C above preindustrial levels, resulting in greater transition risks (financial or reputational) to businesses as they decarbonize; or 

  • Temperatures increase by 3°C or more from preindustrial levels, resulting in greater physical risks such as sea-level rise, catastrophic weather events and loss of arable land. 

 
Each of these scenarios would yield different political, social, technological and environmental considerations and outcomes. As a result, the global economy and market conditions in each scenario would differ. For climate scenario analysis in portfolios to be effective, investors must define a reasonable range of scenarios, supported by data, models and reliable practices, with the aim of assessing the impact on portfolios. 

 

4 Steps for Climate Scenario Analysis

Climate scenario analysis can be categorized into four main stages:

 

  1. Set the question. First, investors need to define what question they want to explore. This will inform how the scenarios are constructed, which variables need to be tested or held constant, and the required outputs. 

     

  2. Build the scenarios. Investors can either choose pre-defined scenarios provided by organizations such as the Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS) or build their own custom scenarios, which offer more nuance and control but are more complex and require a greater understanding of climate science. 

     

  3. Conduct analysis. Mathematical computer models—usually Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs)—draw the relationship between greenhouse gas emissions and social and economic factors. If an investor uses scenarios from organizations like NGFS, then this analysis will already have been completed; for custom scenarios, investors would run this analysis themselves with input from experts who understand how IAMs work. 

     

  4. Use outputs. Outputs can be used directly to inform portfolio risk analysis or bottom-up company analysis. Potential outputs could include prices for energy, carbon and other commodities, as well as imports/exports, emissions, supply/demand volumes and land use.

 
The resulting outputs can then be used to analyze portfolio impacts for overall climate change risks. This can take the form of bottom-up company analysis or top-down macroeconomic analysis, generating estimates on factors such as bond yields, inflation or index prices.

 

At each stage, investors may need to find a balance between competing priorities. Most notably, limited resources may constrain the level of detail that can be built in. Some of the challenges involved in using climate scenario modelling based on constantly evolving understandings of climate science cannot yet be resolved, and so the impact of physical risks, such as flooding, may be structurally understated in models. However, most challenges can be managed. 

 

Case Study: Carbon Capture and Pricing Scenarios

Morgan Stanley applied its in-house climate scenario capabilities to a case study that examines two scenarios related to the availability of carbon capture and storage (CCS), an emerging technology used to remove CO2 before, during or after the combustion of fossil fuels or biomass. The International Energy Agency (IEA)1 forecasts that meeting global net-zero targets requires a significant contribution from innovative technologies such as CCS, which is widely used in climate scenario analysis, but has yet to live up to its promise because of high costs and challenges with scale. 

 

We considered two scenarios: CCS technologies being able to remove either 23 or 15 gigatons of carbon from the atmosphere by 2050, with other variables such as population, GDP and government policy on emissions held constant. Analyzing these paths shows different outcomes for CO2 emissions, carbon pricing, primary energy mix and electricity costs. Taking the carbon price as an example, when CCS technologies can sequester 23 gigatons of carbon, the 2050 carbon price is approximately $750 per ton of CO2. By contrast, when CCS can only remove 15 gigatons, the carbon price shoots up to approximately $1,100 per ton of CO2, reflecting higher costs of CCS in the lower volume scenario.  

 

This analysis could inform a range of potential portfolio outcomes, including long-term fossil fuel demand, the impact on earnings for companies in energy and beyond, energy consumption and household spending.

 

Quantifying Climate Impacts on Portfolios Despite Complexity

While climate change scenario analysis is a relatively new practice, it echoes how investors already assess the global markets and economy. Understandably, a constant stream of new climate change findings, data, policies, technologies and dynamics make risk assessment seem daunting. But climate scenario analysis can serve as a useful tool for institutional investors who want a methodical approach to understanding the potential impacts of climate change in their portfolios.

Other Articles You May Like

Focus on Finance: Affording Care with Bridge Loans in Florida

If there is a sudden health-related event that forces a move for your loved one into a senior living community, time is of the essence in figuring out ways to meet the financial obligations. It is common for families to struggle with the upfront costs and be unprepared for move-in fees, monthly rent, and costs associated with making this move. One resource you can consider is using a bridge loan which provides access to the needed funds quickly so that you can get the senior living lifestyle your loved one wants and deserves. Meridian communities have partnered with Elderlife Financial in providing the Elderlife Bridge Loan which is a financial bridge, allowing you to pay for care now while waiting on permanent funding. When approved for a bridge loan, funds can be disbursed within 24 hours, which can help ease the burden on a family navigating difficult decisions. The borrowed funds can be paid back in just a few months or a little over a year, whenever the family funds that were previously tied up become available. Examples include receiving the proceeds from selling a home, liquidating retirement assets, or receiving the retroactive check from VA Benefits.To learn more about other resources to affording care, call us today. We are here for you!

Navigating The Financial Aspects Of Senior Living

If you've decided that your loved one has reached a point in life where they need help with activities of daily living, you've already completed perhaps the most emotionally taxing step in the process. As for the financial aspect of shifting from an independent living environment to the next level of care, it can be complicated-but that's where we come in.Our senior living communities provide all-inclusive care that includes housekeeping, meals, transportation, and entertainment. Because these things are included in your monthly rent, without the recurring costs associated with owning and maintaining your own home, you may just find that senior living is more affordable than you thought."Finances.'how am I going to be able to pay for this' - that's always our residents' first concern," said Placement Specialist Sarah Ingram, of Best Life for Seniors.Our goal is to provide you with a framework and the tools to help you navigate the financial aspect of your journey. When your loved one reaches that point in life where they need the support provided in an assisted living community, or the help administered in a memory care community, the costs associated can be significant. Unfortunately, those figures can induce a kind of "sticker shock," which can deter people from seeking the care that would improve their overall quality of life, health, and safety.But it doesn't have to be that way. There is help available, although many don't realize it exists.FUNDING BREAKDOWNPaying for full-time senior care services can be broken down into two general categories: Private Pay and Assisted Pay.PRIVATE PAYOf the two methods, private pay is the most straightforward. Simply put: the resident, or the resident's friends or family, pays their monthly fees in full out of pocket.Those with the means to do so foot the bill themselves without outside assistance. At some communities and in certain states, private pay is the only method available.ASSISTED PAYWhen a prospective resident begins the process of inquiry into our community, one of the first things we ask about is their or their spouse's military background.Aid & Attendance BenefitsVeterans, and their spouses, who served during specific time periods are entitled to government benefits designated to help pay for the cost of assisted living and memory care services. The benefits can be significant: up to $3,253 per month, tax-free, for veterans and their families.The requirements do vary somewhat depending on when the veteran served, but the following are included:Minimum ServiceNinety (90) days during a period of war as outlined by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs (VA).Wartime Service DatesWorld War I: April 6, 1917 - Nov. 11, 1918World War II: Dec. 7, 1941 - Dec. 31, 1946Korean War: June 27, 1950 - Jan. 31, 1955Vietnam War: Aug. 5, 1964 - May 7, 1975Gulf War: Aug. 2, 1990 - through a future date to be set by law or Presidential Proclamation. The veteran is not required to have served in combat-if a veteran was stationed in Kansas in 1952, not Korea, that would still count.Veterans who served during the Gulf War era are required to have twenty-four (24) months of service, or a "full tour."Age / StatusTo be eligible for Veteran-Directed Care, veterans must be 65 years old or be designated "unemployable" (veterans designated "unemployable" tend to be receiving Social Security disability already).Discharge StatusHonorable or medical discharge.Unfortunately, it can be difficult for some veterans to access their benefits. Many veterans who try to navigate the VA system themselves, but either don't hear back from the VA or are denied coverage by the VA due to a discharge issue. However, it is possible to petition the VA for a change of discharge status.Additionally, few veterans describe the VA system as "user-friendly."Maybe you, or your loved one, has encountered a VA-related roadblock. Maybe you haven't yet begun the process, but you are aware that it can be time-consuming and difficult.For those seeking assistance navigating the VA's system of benefits, we recommend working with our partners at Patriot Angels because having experts on your side can make all the difference.Patriot AngelsPatriot Angels is a Tennessee-based non-profit organization that specializes in helping veterans navigate the VA system to receive the benefits they have earned through their service."We help veterans and their spouses and widows supplement the cost for senior living. Our first goal is to educate families," said Patriot Angels Special Project Manager Erin Walker. "About eight of ten veterans and their spouses don't know these benefits exist."The United States Department of Veterans Affairs doesn't advertise the benefits and doesn't make the process to obtain the benefits easy."We just don't want someone to automatically rule themselves out," Walker said. "Do not rule someone out based on information you've heard in the past. That's why we're here: to help you answer these questions."Patriot Angels asks that veterans send whatever discharge documents they have in order to help the non-profit identify service dates and discharge status. Patriot Angels also looks for key dates to establish eligibility for benefits.One of the main reasons that it is important for veterans and their spouses to go to Patriot Angels early in the process is to avoid financial missteps, like missing out on funds that can pay for care. Their mission to help make sure you remain financially secure. And it's important to note that there is absolutely no need to spend down all of your money before making that call to Patriot Angels."Veterans usually come to us when they're getting moved in and they need extra money each month to help pay for the care they need - it expedites the process when the veteran is already living in the community," Walker said. "Our goal is to be able to assist families. We can usually do it in about thirty to forty-five days. The VA side of the process usually takes about one-hundred-and-twenty days, but the VA will reimburse veterans for expenses incurred during that wait time after the process has officially begun."Patriot Angels has provided invaluable help to many of our residents, and they're able to help people access their benefits quickly."Most of the people we work with are eligible for Aid and Attendance benefits," Ingram said. "Working with Patriot Angels makes the process so much quicker than going straight through the VA without any additional support."For more information, call the Patriot Angels at (844) 757-3047, or go to their website at patriotangels.com.Medicaid / Personal Care ServicesFor many, the answer to "How can I afford this," comes through the help of the North Carolina Medicaid Personal Care Services (PCS) program.Medicaid PCS is a health assistance program for North Carolina Medicaid beneficiaries who, because of a physical or developmental disability, cognitive impairment, or other chronic health condition, are unable to accomplish tasks that they would ordinarily do for themselves if they were not disabled. Covered services under this program include the services that are provided to residents at the Community-assistance with activities of daily living (ADLs) such as bathing, dressing, mobility, toileting, and eating. In order to qualify for the Medicaid PCS program, an individual must first qualify for North Carolina Medicaid. North Carolina Medicaid is available to individuals who are:Age 65 or older,Blind or disabled,Infants or children under the age of 21,Pregnant,Low-income individuals or part of low-income families,In need of long-term care, orReceiving Medicare.In addition, to be eligible for North Carolina Medicaid, an individual must also be: A resident of the state of North Carolina, A U.S. national, citizen, permanent resident, or legal alien, In need of health care/insurance assistance, and In a financial situation that would be characterized as low income or very low income. Until January of 2023, Medicaid's monthly income limits had not been raised or adjusted for inflation for 20 years while Social Security benefits had increased each year. For North Carolina, the income limit for Medicaid to help fund assisted living is $1,355 per month; to help fund memory care, it's $1,717 per month. In addition, your resources must not be more than $2,000 for an individual. Resources include cash, bank accounts, retirement accounts, stocks and bonds, cash value of life insurance policies, and other investments. For those who are living solely on Social Security, those numbers are usually manageable, but many people have additional income from pensions and other sources which can quickly push their monthly income totals above the limits.Pre-planning is vitally important because all assets must be out of the resident's name five years before the resident becomes eligible for Medicaid. It's important to be prepared because medical emergencies cannot be predicted. Everything-from vehicles to homes and real estate-must be divested five years before you become eligible for Medicaid.For many, a spend down-the process of reducing your income and assets in order to be eligible for Medicaid-is a valuable tool. However, there are requirements in place for the spend-down process. Money spent on the senior's care, whether it's a burial plot or paying for medical care, is an example of an acceptable choice when spending down one's assets.There are also eligibility requirements to consider. For example, people who move to North Carolina in order to move into senior living must have either lived here for a minimum of six months or have established a permanent residence for a minimum of 60 days in order to become eligible for Medicaid assistance.When you apply for Medicaid, the state of North Carolina will initiate what's called a 60-month Medicaid Look-Back Period. This means that the state will examine all your asset transfers over the past five years to ensure that no assets were sold for less than fair market value or given away. This look-back review includes examining asset transfers made by one's spouse. If the state determines that the look-back rule has been violated, the state assumes that the violation was committed to meet Medicaid's asset limit. The state will then calculate and impose a penalty period of Medicaid ineligibility.An online spend down calculator can help you determine exactly how much of your assets must be spent down in order for you to be eligible for Medicaid long term care. The spend down calculator is available here: medicaidplanningassistance.org/medicaid-spend-down-calculator.Alternative AssetsWhen the time comes to work out how to pay for long-term care, it's important to explore all options. There are some methods of generating funds that work well for people but can be overlooked.Life InsuranceSome people have life insurance policies that can be sold, converted, or liquidated through a viatical settlement. A viatical settlement is an arrangement whereby an individual sells their life insurance policy to a third party for less than its mature value in order to benefit from the proceeds while still alive. Alternatives to Selling Your HomeMany residents sell their homes as they transition to long-term care. For others, it makes more financial sense to take out a reverse mortgage or to open a home equity line of credit. Another option is to rent out your home in order to fund your care.INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY: The materials and information on this website have been prepared or assembled by the Community and are intended for informational purposes only. The information is general in nature and is not intended to be, and should not be relied upon as, legal advice. Some of the information may be out-of-date and may not reflect the most current legal developments regarding Medicaid eligibility. This website contains information on legal issues and is not a substitute for legal advice from a qualified attorney licensed in the appropriate jurisdiction. Establishing Medicaid and Medicaid PCS eligibility can be a complicated process, and the Community urges you to consult an attorney or specialist in North Carolina elder law to help you navigate these issues. The Community expressly disclaims all liability with respect to actions taken or not taken based on information contained or missing from this website.

How to Apply for Long-Term Care Medicaid in Colorado

How to Apply for Long-Term Care Medicaid in ColoradoApplying for Medicaid can be a daunting task, especially when it comes to long-term care. However, with the right guidance and resources, the process can be much smoother. This guide is designed for seniors, caregivers, and Colorado residents to help them understand how to apply for long-term care Medicaid in Colorado. Understanding Long-Term Care MedicaidLong-term care Medicaid provides financial assistance to those who need help with daily living activities, such as bathing, dressing, and eating. It covers care provided in various settings including nursing homes, assisted living facilities, and even at home. Why You Shouldn't Apply AloneGiven the high volume of applications and the complexity of the process, we do not recommend submitting an application on your own. Mistakes can delay approval or result in denial. Should you choose to apply on your own, we will give you the information and tools you need during our free initial consultation with you. Schedule a free consultation here  - calendly.com/doinggoodforothers Steps to Apply for Long-Term Care Medicaid in ColoradoStep 1: Find The Applicants DHS OfficeThe first step in applying for Medicaid in Colorado is to find the applicants local Department of Human Services (DHS) office. This is where you will submit your financial application. Find the Applicants DHS office here - cdhs.colorado.gov/contact-your-county Step 2: Submit a Financial ApplicationOnce you have located your local DHS office, you will need to submit a financial application. This form will require detailed information about your income, assets, and expenses. Step 3: Determine Financial EligibilityBefore proceeding with the application, it's crucial to determine if you qualify financially for Medicaid or VA Aid & Attendance benefits. Strategies exist to access benefits while protecting your personal assets, and a Certified Medicaid Planner (CMP) can help you maximize your benefits. Find out if you qualify - doinggoodforothers.com/financialinformation Step 4: Schedule a Health AssessmentAfter qualifying financially, you will need to schedule a level of care assessment, also known as a health assessment, with the Applicants Single Entry Point. This evaluation will determine the level of care you require. Schedule a health assessment - hcfp.colorado.gov/case-management-agency-directory Step 5: Skip the Hassle of Applying Alone Schedule an AppointmentIf you find the application process overwhelming, you can skip figuring out how to apply on your own by scheduling an appointment with our experts.  Schedule an appointment with a Certified Medicaid Planner - calendly.com/doinggoodforothers Our 4-Step Process for Application AssuranceWe have developed a streamlined 4-step process to help you feel relief about your loved ones care and save money. 1. Schedule a Free Initial ConsultationLearn more about what we can do to preserve your assets by scheduling a free initial consultation. 2. Make a PlanThrough an assessment of your financial circumstances, we will create a roadmap of the best options for you. 3. Pick an OptionWe explore legitimate opportunities to preserve your assets. 4. Gain BenefitsSelect the best option, and we will complete a successful application for gained benefits. Applying for long-term care Medicaid in Colorado doesn't have to be stressful. By following these steps and seeking professional guidance, you can ensure a smoother application process and maximize your benefits.For personalized assistance, schedule a free consultation with one of our Certified Medicaid Planners (CMP) today. Learn more and schedule now! - calendly.com/doinggoodforothers

Local Services By This Author

Morgan Stanley Wealth Management

Financial Advisor 8889 Pelican Bay Boulevard, Naples, Florida, 34108

At Morgan Stanley, we advise, originate, trade, manage and distribute capital for people, governments and institutions, always with a standard of excellence and guided by our core values.Morgan Stanley is dedicated to providing first-class service to our clients, in a way that reflects our commitment to creating a more sustainable future and fostering stronger communities around the world. In each line of business, we strive to demonstrate our belief in the power of transformative thinking, innovative strategies and leading-edge solutionsand in the ability of capital to work for the benefit of all society.