IMPROPER MONEY TRANSFERS COULD BECOME CRIMINAL
Advocates in Aging| Law Office of Wiesner Smith
Mar 24, 2021
Florida - Sarasota, Bradenton & Charlotte Counties
Email US
Click to Email Us
Tucked away in the fraud and abuse section of a health insurance reform bill that President Clinton signed in August is a provision that makes it a felony for a person to transfer assets less than three years before applying for long-term care benefits under Medicaid. Medicaid, the health care program for the poor, is jointly financed by state and federal governments. The program pays more than half of all the nursing home bills in this country and is one of the fastest growing segments of state budgets.
Medicare, the fully federal health care program for those 65 and older, generally does not cover nursing home bills. Nor do private medigap policies. That leaves only private funds, long-term care insurance or Medicaid to pay for nursing home care.
With nursing home bills averaging $40,000 year, many elderly people simply cannot afford to pay them and must immediately turn to Medicaid for help. Other people enter nursing homes as paying patients, but turn to Medicaid once they use up their savings.
But the concern is over the increasing number of middle- and upper-income people who, with the help of attorneys, arrange their finances so as to preserve the bulk of their assets for their heirs while becoming poor enough - at least on paper - to qualify for government nursing home payments.
Under current law, anyone who transfers assets within three years of applying for Medicaid can be denied benefits for a period of time. The new law, which takes effect next year, will make that kind of asset shifting a criminal offense, punishable by up to five years in jail and or a $25,000 fine.
There are differing opinions as to how the new law will actually affect the elderly, their families and their legal advisors.
"The intent is not to put Grand-ma in jail but to have a chilling effect on the Medicaid estate planning bar," said Stephen Moses, research director of LTC Inc., a private firm that designs and markets long-term care insurance.
"I don't expect anybody to be prosecuted under it," Moses added. But he hopes the mere threat of criminal prosecution will refocus the national debate on how to finance long-term care.
Ira Wiesner, president of the National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys (NAELA), whose members specialize in Medicaid estate planning, called the new law "unprecedented" and said it was decidedly the wrong approach to long-term care problems.
"Out of an inability or unwillingness to deal with the fundamental issue of society's need to take care of its citizens who suffer long-term chronic illness, the best solution they can come up with is putting seniors in jail," Wiesner said. "They are hurting the wrong people and they are not addressing the problem."
Moses of LTC Inc. believes the way to address the problem of long-term care is for people with money to take personal responsibility for their future. That means using their private savings or purchasing long-term care insurance (which his firm sells) to pay for their own nursing home bills, preserving Medicaid's scarce resources for the truly needy.
"It is very sad that it has come to the point that Congress concluded that it has to criminalize Medicaid estate planning," said Moses. "But I understand the anger and frustration of public policy makers who have been unable, despite 15 years of attempts, to constrain the flow of these funds to middle- and upper-middle-class seniors."
James Felman, a criminal attorney in Tampa, Fla., who analyzed the new law for NAELA at Wiesner's request, said he doesn't expect the government will ever get the chance to flex its muscle on this issue.
"I cannot imagine the federal government would have much interest in prosecuting a helpless old person," Felman said. The more likely targets, he said, would be the beneficiaries of an egregious case of asset transfer - for example, adult children who would inherit a nursing home patient's money, or the lawyers or financial advisors who set up the plan.
But Felman says the law is so poorly worded that he doubts it would survive a court challenge.
Felman explained that the law only applies criminal sanctions when someone is denied Medicaid benefits.
Submitted By: Advocates in Aging| Law Office of Wiesner Smith- click for more information*
Written By: Mary Beth Franklin, Maturity News Service
Other Articles You May Like
A Special Visit: Meals on Wheels America President & CEO Joins Florida Chapter Conference
It was a momentous occasion in Bradenton on May 1, 2025, as we welcomed a very special guest Ellie Hollander, President & CEO of Meals on Wheels America. Her visit was more than ceremonial; it was a heartfelt celebration of community, service, and the vital work being done across Florida to nourish and support our seniors.Ellie flew in from the Washington, D.C. area as the keynote speaker for the Meals on Wheels Florida annual conference, proudly hosted this year by Meals on Wheels PLUS of Manatee. Ellies schedule was packed, but that did not stop her from doing an interview with MySuncoast ABC-7 telling viewers how critical the meal program is to our homebound seniors. Next, Ellie hit the road and delivered meals to some of our senior clients and talked with our volunteers. Ellie also stopped by our Friendship Dining Center program, and participated in a music game the clients love.The Members of the Florida Chapter of Meals on Wheels America named Maribeth Phillips, our President & CEO, as their Board President earlier this year. Maribeth invited Ellie to attend and kickoff the conference. Ellie shared valuable insights with the members in attendance, and her words reenergized the room!The conference included meal providers from across the state, with over 20 different organizations attending. Attendees also heard from Bob Blancato, Executive Director of NANASP, also from Washington, D.C.; Bradenton Police Detective, Jim Curulla on senior scams; Sandra Tapfumaneyi, Chief of Emergency Management Sarasota; Louise Gallagher on Senior Mental Health; and Jennifer Huber from FPL. Chef2Home provided a delicious breakfast and lunch.We are proud to be part of the national network of Meals on Wheels America and grateful to be a part of the state-wide chapter, Meals on Wheels Florida, both working every day to ensure no senior goes hungry.
Help Fight Summer Hunger in Manatee County
As summer approaches, many children in our community are looking forward to sunshine, fun, and time with friends. But for far too many, summer brings something else-hunger.When school cafeterias close for the summer, thousands of local children lose access to the nutritious meals they depend on. Families already struggling to make ends meet are faced with even more pressure. The emotional toll is real. No parent should have to worry if they can feed their child, and no child should go to bed with an empty stomach.At The Food Bank of Manatee, we are stepping up to meet the need. We partner with over 100 local food pantries across Manatee County to reach the families who need us mostbut we cant do it alone.This summer, our goal is to provide: 22,500 meals each week across the 9-week summer break. Thats more than 200,000 meals for children and familiesand every dollar makes a difference.Just $15 provides 10 meals; $30 provides 20 meals; a gift of $150 will provide 100 meals!We know that many in our community want to make a difference. With your support, we can ensure no child goes hungry during the summer months.Please consider making a gift today and sharing this message with others who want to help too. A link to our page is below. A $25,000 Matching Gift to feed children this summer has been offered by an anonymous fund at Manatee Community Foundation. Gifts will be matched $1 for $1 up to $25,000.The Food Bank of Manatee is the only food bank based in our county. We anticipate continued need as families look for nutritional support. Your help matters now more than ever! Please give today!Together, we can bring relief, peace of mind, and full bellies to those who need it most.
Celebrating the Heart of Our Mission: Volunteer Luncheon Honors Our Outstanding Volunteers
On Monday, April 7, 2025, we had the joy and honor of hosting our annual Volunteer Luncheon, a heartfelt celebration dedicated to the incredible individuals who make our mission possible each and every day. Held in a spirit of gratitude and community, the event brought together volunteers with over 100 hours of service for a beautiful luncheon provided by Metz Chef 2 Home. The highlight of the event was the presentation of awards to several outstanding volunteers who have gone above and beyond in their service. From delivering meals with a smile to lending a helping hand wherever needed, these volunteers embody the true spirit of giving.The 2025 award recipients included:Champions Circle: Ten Years of ServiceDan WilhelmChampions Circle: 300+ Hours of ServiceTerri HillChampions Circle: 300+ Hours of ServicePat McDonaldOutstanding Food Bank Volunteer: Terri HillOutstanding Volunteer Ambassador: Veronica Brandon-MillerOutstanding Youth Volunteer: Jonathan MaassenMost Generous Group Ambassador: Lakewood Ranch Elks LodgeOutstanding Volunteer Group: First WatchOutstanding Administrative Volunteer: Barbara BrownOutstanding Friendship Dining Center Volunteer: Pam O ConnorOutstanding Car Loader: Charlie GunnOutstanding Warehouse Volunteer: Lana PaulRookies of the Year: Jeff and Christy MohlerOutstanding Daybreak Adult Day Center Volunteer: Larry BreidenbachOutstanding Telephone Reassurance Volunteer: Reina HuertaVolunteer of the Year: Terri HillTo every volunteer who gives their time and heartthank you. Our Volunteers are the reason we are able to serve our neighbors in need with care, dignity, and hope. We look forward to another year of making a difference together.