IMPROPER MONEY TRANSFERS COULD BECOME CRIMINAL
Advocates in Aging| Law Office of Wiesner Smith
Mar 24, 2021
Florida - Sarasota, Bradenton & Charlotte Counties
Email US
Click to Email Us
Tucked away in the fraud and abuse section of a health insurance reform bill that President Clinton signed in August is a provision that makes it a felony for a person to transfer assets less than three years before applying for long-term care benefits under Medicaid. Medicaid, the health care program for the poor, is jointly financed by state and federal governments. The program pays more than half of all the nursing home bills in this country and is one of the fastest growing segments of state budgets.
Medicare, the fully federal health care program for those 65 and older, generally does not cover nursing home bills. Nor do private medigap policies. That leaves only private funds, long-term care insurance or Medicaid to pay for nursing home care.
With nursing home bills averaging $40,000 year, many elderly people simply cannot afford to pay them and must immediately turn to Medicaid for help. Other people enter nursing homes as paying patients, but turn to Medicaid once they use up their savings.
But the concern is over the increasing number of middle- and upper-income people who, with the help of attorneys, arrange their finances so as to preserve the bulk of their assets for their heirs while becoming poor enough - at least on paper - to qualify for government nursing home payments.
Under current law, anyone who transfers assets within three years of applying for Medicaid can be denied benefits for a period of time. The new law, which takes effect next year, will make that kind of asset shifting a criminal offense, punishable by up to five years in jail and or a $25,000 fine.
There are differing opinions as to how the new law will actually affect the elderly, their families and their legal advisors.
"The intent is not to put Grand-ma in jail but to have a chilling effect on the Medicaid estate planning bar," said Stephen Moses, research director of LTC Inc., a private firm that designs and markets long-term care insurance.
"I don't expect anybody to be prosecuted under it," Moses added. But he hopes the mere threat of criminal prosecution will refocus the national debate on how to finance long-term care.
Ira Wiesner, president of the National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys (NAELA), whose members specialize in Medicaid estate planning, called the new law "unprecedented" and said it was decidedly the wrong approach to long-term care problems.
"Out of an inability or unwillingness to deal with the fundamental issue of society's need to take care of its citizens who suffer long-term chronic illness, the best solution they can come up with is putting seniors in jail," Wiesner said. "They are hurting the wrong people and they are not addressing the problem."
Moses of LTC Inc. believes the way to address the problem of long-term care is for people with money to take personal responsibility for their future. That means using their private savings or purchasing long-term care insurance (which his firm sells) to pay for their own nursing home bills, preserving Medicaid's scarce resources for the truly needy.
"It is very sad that it has come to the point that Congress concluded that it has to criminalize Medicaid estate planning," said Moses. "But I understand the anger and frustration of public policy makers who have been unable, despite 15 years of attempts, to constrain the flow of these funds to middle- and upper-middle-class seniors."
James Felman, a criminal attorney in Tampa, Fla., who analyzed the new law for NAELA at Wiesner's request, said he doesn't expect the government will ever get the chance to flex its muscle on this issue.
"I cannot imagine the federal government would have much interest in prosecuting a helpless old person," Felman said. The more likely targets, he said, would be the beneficiaries of an egregious case of asset transfer - for example, adult children who would inherit a nursing home patient's money, or the lawyers or financial advisors who set up the plan.
But Felman says the law is so poorly worded that he doubts it would survive a court challenge.
Felman explained that the law only applies criminal sanctions when someone is denied Medicaid benefits.
Submitted By: Advocates in Aging| Law Office of Wiesner Smith- click for more information*
Written By: Mary Beth Franklin, Maturity News Service
Other Articles You May Like
Navigating Long Term Senior Care Costs: What if My Parents Run Out of Money?
As we journey through life, many people find themselves facing one of the most pressing concerns: ensuring that they provide care and support to their loved ones, particularly their aging parents, as they transition into their senior years. Long-term senior care frequently raises questions and concerns, with one of the most common worries being, What if my parents run out of money?The cost of senior care services can indeed be a significant burden on families. Many are apprehensive about the affordability of these services and the potential financial strain they might impose. This is where a comprehensive continuum of care approach, like the one offered by Grace Pointe of Greeley, can make all the difference.Tailored Care for Your Unique NeedsOur team of experienced care professionals adopts a personalized approach to assess the specific care needs of each resident. We commit to ensuring that you dont pay for services that you or your loved one dont need. This ensures that you wont bear unnecessary costs, and your loved ones will receive the appropriate level of care to enhance their quality of life.If the affordability of long-term senior care concerns you, Grace Pointes approach is here to help. We dedicate ourselves to providing the right care at the right cost, supporting both your financial peace of mind and your loved ones well-being.To learn more about our long-term senior care services and our continuum of care approach, visit our Grace Pointe of Greeleys Long-Term Senior Care Services page.Frequently Asked Questions About Long-Term Senior CareAt Grace Pointe, we understand the financial concerns that come with long-term senior care, and were here to put your mind at ease. Our continuum of care services is designed to ensure affordability while providing your loved ones with the precise level of care they need. We understand that every individual is unique, and their care requirements can vary greatly which is why we have compiled this list of FAQs about long term senior care services below.What is long-term senior care, and when is it needed?Long-term senior care is a comprehensive service designed to provide assistance and support for seniors who may require help with daily activities due to age-related challenges or medical conditions. It becomes necessary when individuals find it increasingly difficult to maintain their independence and well-being.How do I know which type of long-term senior care is suitable for my loved one?Our experienced care professionals at Grace Pointe will assess your loved ones individual needs and recommend the most appropriate level of care. We believe in personalized care plans to ensure your loved one receives the best possible care.What is the cost of long-term senior care at Grace Pointe, and how can I afford it?The cost of long-term senior care varies depending on the level of care and services required. Grace Pointe offers a continuum of care approach, ensuring you only pay for the care your loved one needs. We will work with you to explore financing options, including community resources for Medicaid and Veterans benefits, to make care more affordable.Can I visit my loved one in long-term senior care at Grace Pointe of Greeley?Yes, we encourage family visits and understand the importance of staying connected. We also encourage you to enjoy activities and events to see the life of Grace Pointe experienced by your family members. There are some guidelines for visiting after hours to ensure the safety and comfort of the Grace Pointe residents, which can be discussed with our staff.How can I learn more about Grace Pointes long-term senior care options?You can explore more details about our long-term senior care services on our Long-Term Care Services page. Feel free to contact our team for specific information and to request a tour.How can Grace Pointe of Greeley help ensure that I dont pay for services my loved one doesnt need in the long term?At Grace Pointe, we understand the importance of affordability in long-term senior care. We offer a continuum of care approach, which means we tailor care plans to your loved ones specific needs. By doing so, we ensure that you only pay for the necessary services, maximizing affordability while maintaining high-quality care. Can I modify my loved ones care plan if their needs change over time?Yes, we understand that care needs can change. At Grace Pointe, we regularly review care plans and adjust them to accommodate changing requirements to ensure your loved one receives the best care.For answers to common questions about long-term senior care and all our services, visit our FAQ page.Dont let financial concerns hold you back from providing the best care for your aging parents. Grace Pointe of Greeley is here to support you every step of the way. Reach out to our care team with any other questions you may have about your familys care.
Time for tax-loss harvesting?
As you know, the gig economy has been booming over the past several years. If youre thinking of using your skills to take on a side gig, what should you do with the money youll make?Theres no one right answer for everyone, and the decisions you make should be based on your individual situation. And of course, you may simply need the extra income to support your lifestyle and pay the bills. But if you already have your cash flow in good shape, and you have some freedom with your gig money, consider these suggestions: Contribute more to your IRA. If you couldnt afford to contribute the maximum amount to your IRA, you may find it easier to do so when you have additional money coming in from a side gig. For the 2023 tax year, you can put in up to $6,500 to a traditional or Roth IRA, or $7,500 if youre 50 or older. (Starting in 2024, this extra $1,000 catch-up contribution amount may be indexed for inflation.) The amount you can contribute to a Roth IRA is reduced, and eventually eliminated, at certain income levels. Look for new investment opportunities. If youre already maxing out your IRA, you might be able to find other investment possibilities for your side gig money. For example, if you have young children, perhaps you could use some of the money to invest in a 529 education savings plan. A 529 plan offers potential tax advantages and can be used for college, qualified trade school programs, and possibly some K-12 expenses. Please keep in mind that potential tax advantages will vary from state to state. Build an emergency fund. Life is full of unexpected events and some can be quite expensive. What if you needed a major car repair or required a medical procedure that wasnt totally covered by your health insurance? Would you have the cash available to pay these bills? If not, would you be forced to dip into your IRA or 401(k)? This might not be a good move, as it could incur taxes and penalties, and deprive you of resources you might eventually need for retirement. Thats why you might want to use your gig earnings to help fund an emergency fund containing several months worth of living expenses, with the money kept in a liquid, low-risk account. To avoid being tempted to dip into your emergency fund, you may want to keep it separate from your daily spending accounts. Pay down debts. Most of us will always carry some debts, but we can usually find ways to include the bigger ones mortgage, car payments and so on into our monthly budgets. Its often the smaller debt payments, frequently associated with high-interest-rate credit cards, that cause us the most trouble, in terms of affecting our cash flow. If you can use some of your side gig money to pay down these types of debts, you could possibly ease some of the financial stress you might be feeling. And instead of directing money to pay for things you purchased in the past, you could use the funds to invest for your future.As weve seen, your side gig money could open several promising windows of opportunity so take a look through all of them. Chad Choate III, AAMS828 3rd Avenue WestBradenton, FL 34205941-462-2445chad.chaote@edwardjones.com This article was written by Edward Jones for use by your local Edward Jones Financial Advisor. Edward Jones, Member SIPC
Time for tax-loss harvesting?
Its been a bumpy year for the financial markets which means that some of your investments may have underperformed or lost value. Can you use these losses to your advantage?Its possible. If you have some investments that have lost value, you could sell them to offset taxable capital gains from other investments. If your losses exceed gains for the year, you could use the remaining losses to offset up to $3,000 of ordinary income. And any amount over $3,000 can be carried forward to offset gains in future years. This tax-loss harvesting can be advantageous if you plan to sell investments that youve held in taxable accounts for years and that have grown significantly in value. And you might receive some gains even if you take no action yourself. For example, when you own mutual funds, the fund manager can decide to sell stocks or other investments within the funds portfolio and then pay you a portion of the proceeds. These payments, known as capital gains distributions, are taxable to you whether you take them as cash or reinvest them back into the fund. Still, despite the possible tax benefits of selling investments whose price has fallen, you need to consider carefully whether such a move is in your best interest. If an investment has a clear place in your holdings, and it offers good business fundamentals and favorable prospects, you might not want to sell it just because its value has dropped. On the other hand, if the investments youre thinking of selling are quite similar to others you own, it might make sense to sell, take the tax loss and then use the proceeds of the sale to purchase new investments that can help fill any gaps in your portfolio. If you do sell an investment and reinvest the funds, youll want to be sure your new investment is different in nature from the one you sold. Otherwise, you could risk triggering the wash sale rule, which states that if you sell an investment at a loss and buy the same or a substantially identical investment within 30 days before or after the sale, the loss is generally disallowed for income tax purposes.Heres one more point to keep in mind about tax-loss harvesting: Youll need to take into account just how long youve held the investments youre considering selling. Thats because long-term losses are first applied against long-term gains, while short-term losses are first applied against short-term gains. (Long-term is defined as more than a year; short-term is one year or less.) If you have excess losses in one category, you can then apply them to gains of either type. Long-term capital gains are taxed at 0%, 15% or 20%, depending on your income, while short-term gains are taxed at your ordinary income tax rate. So, from a tax perspective, taking short-term losses could provide greater benefits if your tax rate is higher than the highest capital gains rate.Youll want to contact your tax advisor to determine whether tax-loss harvesting is appropriate for your situation and youll need to do it soon because the deadline is Dec. 31. But whether you pursue this technique this year or not, you may want to keep it in mind for the future because youll always have investment tax issues to consider. Chad Choate III, AAMS828 3rd Avenue WestBradenton, FL 34205941-462-2445chad.chaote@edwardjones.com This article was written by Edward Jones for use by your local Edward Jones Financial Advisor.Edward Jones, Member SIPC