The Payer Cost of Congestive Heart Failure Management: A case study of cost savings with supportive in-home health care

Author

Brightstar Care of MSC

For more information about the author, click to view their website: BrightStar Care of Venice and Port Charlotte

Posted on

Aug 03, 2023

share-this
Share This

The Challenge: Cost Containment for Chronic Conditions 

Management of Congestive Heart Failure is extensive and expensive, placing heavy demands on health care system resources due to long hospital stays, multiple readmissions and other ongoing medical needs. As CHF progresses, acute episodes become more frequent and can lead to higher risks of mortality. [1] 

Because CHF symptoms can be non-specific or attributed to other causes, gradual or abrupt, and vary from person to person, quality care management with clinical oversight is vital to improved outcomes. Factors that contribute to the complex nature of disease management for CHF include: 

  • Congestive Heart Failure is one of the most expensive diagnoses. 

  • Patients can present with varying symptoms and experience a rapid change in their health. 

  • Post-discharge instructions may be hard for patients to follow, either due to a lack of understanding or difficulty making changes due to deeply ingrained habits. 

  • This chronic condition is often exacerbated by lifestyle choices such as lack of exercise, poor nutrition, smoking, etc. 

  • Lack of medication compliance or dosing errors can compromise recovery. 

Proving superior clinical outcomes has been a long-standing challenge for the home care industry due to fragmented care standards across states, the lack of standardized measures in personal care, and the lack of visibility home health care agencies have on claims data for patients. 

The Solution: Nurse-Led In-Home Personal Care 

BrightStar Care’s nurse-led care teams coordinate post-acute transitions and provide oversight on medication compliance, patient education and ongoing monitoring of patient change of condition. This care can help reduce avoidable hospitalizations, medication errors, emergency room usage and improves quality of life, while also delivering a reduction in health care costs and providing value creation for payers. For patients with Congestive Heart Failure and other chronic conditions, this care is essential. 

Many of the services that BrightStar Care has been providing for the last 20 years can help reduce poor patient outcomes and lessen health care costs. Here are some of the key factors that contribute to accomplishing these goals [2]: 

  • Smoother care transitions. 

  • Improved discharge instruction understanding and compliance. 

  • Enhanced patient education and support. 

  • Focus on symptom monitoring and management. 

  • Intervention to reduce acute heart failure incidents. 

  • Improved quality of life, improved self care and end-of-life care. 
     

Registered Nurse (RN) oversight for all BrightStar Care clients includes the following: 

  • Review of discharge instructions and transitional care needs, which gives the client and their loved ones an opportunity to absorb and understand this information in a more relaxed home environment. 

  • Initial assessment and reassessments to identify clinical exacerbations. This provides a clinical set of eyes in the field in between appointments and hospitalizations. 

  • Medication reconciliation to identify gaps in medication lists and/or non-compliance. 

  • Education for clients and families on signs and symptoms of disease exacerbation, recommended lifestyle changes and the importance of adherence to the plan of care. 

  • Recommendation of risk mitigation strategies which may include fall reduction, home safety, emergency planning and other helpful insights. 

  • Monitoring changes in condition and escalating to external care teams when appropriate. 



Certified Nursing Assistants (CNAs) and Caregivers provide support under RN oversight. The following services may be performed by CNAs, Caregivers or both based on their scope of practice: 

  • Report changes to RN by answering client specific, disease specific change in condition questions at the end of each shift. The RN is immediately notified and can intervene and/or investigate as needed. 

  • Serve as the “eyes and ears” of the post-discharge Plan of Care (POC) and provide encouragement to the client to follow the plan. The RN is notified of any changes in condition. 

  • Support self-care and/or end-of-life needs. Older adults living with chronic disease can often experience depression, anxiety or other issues that need support. Our staff provides companionship, creates routines, plans safe daily activities and participates in those activities with their clients, which can improve the client’s overall quality of life. 

  • Aid with personal care tasks such as toileting, bathing and grooming, dressing, feeding and ambulating. In addition to providing the client with physical support to do these activities, it also helps reduce falls, decreases infections due to proper hygiene and ensures that the client is eating a healthy diet – all of which contribute to a lower risk of hospitalization and extend the amount of home time. 

  • Provide medication reminders to ensure compliance and reduce the risk of medication errors. 

  • Encourage lifestyle modifications such as exercising, meeting special dietary needs by grocery shopping and/or doing meal prep, smoking cessation support, watching for signs of alcohol mis-use and other healthy habits. 

Although BrightStar Care has observed and documented patient care that reduces the likelihood of avoidable hospitalizations and other expensive care options, we – like most other in-home personal care providers – wanted to have data to validate that personal care can lead to positive outcomes and cost savings for the healthcare ecosystem. 


The Results 

In order to address the lack of data quantifying the benefits of in-home personal care for clients with chronic conditions, BrightStar Care engaged leading health care analytics firm, Avalere Health (Opens in a new window), to evaluate client outcomes and cost benefits of in-home personal care. Avalere Health enables data-driven health care by informing actionable insights, delivering meaningful impact, and driving stronger patient outcomes and business economics. 

The analysis from Avalere Health (Opens in a new window)
 validates BrightStar Care’s delivery of positive outcomes for personal care clients and value for downstream payers.
 Clients receiving in-home personal care experience lower rates of hospitalization, Emergency Department visits and Skilled Nursing Facility utilization across 30 different health care conditions. 

How the study was conducted: Avalere Health compared BrightStar Care clients to a matched control group of Medicare Beneficiaries and assessed the relative utilization of Medicare services between the two populations for different health care conditions with the average age of the population being 80. 

Avalere’s analysis revealed that the change (baseline vs. follow-up) in the total cost of care was up to $29,902 lower for patients who received BrightStar Care services when compared to patients who did not receive services. 

 

Among patients with Congestive Heart Failure, 

the average savings per client was $6,618. [3] 

 

The analysis provides the latest evidence that personal care services, such as medication management, meal preparation, personal care assistance, and patient education, can have a positive impact on overall health, leading, in turn, to a reduction in healthcare costs and value creation for payers. 

When payers partner with in-home personal care companies like BrightStar Care, it can deliver positive results for all parties involved – most importantly, for the patients we care for.  

Learn more how BrightStar Care can help you keep your costs down while providing high-quality in-home care. (Opens in a new window)

  

 

Other Articles You May Like

When Family Caregivers Need a Break Too

When someone you love needs help, stepping in often feels natural.You pick up groceries. Drive Mom to a doctor's appointment. Stop by Dad's house to make dinner. Help with laundry. Call in the morning to make sure medications were taken. Check again at night to be sure everything is okay.At first, these things may not feel like "caregiving."They're simply what families do.But over time, a few helpful tasks can quietly turn into a second job.And somewhere along the way, the caregiver's own needs can begin moving further and further down the list.Family Caregiving Can Be Rewarding and ExhaustingCaring for an aging parent or spouse can be one of life's most meaningful roles.It can also be physically and emotionally demanding.Many family caregivers are balancing several responsibilities at once. They may be working, raising children, managing their own household and trying to maintain relationships while also caring for an aging loved one.There may be appointments to coordinate, meals to prepare, medications to remember, household chores to complete and important decisions to make.And even when the caregiver isn't physically with their loved one, the worry doesn't necessarily stop.Did Mom eat today?Did Dad remember his appointment?What if she falls when I'm not there?Should I stop by again tonight?That constant responsibility can take a toll.Watch for Signs of Caregiver BurnoutCaregiver stress doesn't always arrive dramatically.Like many changes associated with aging, it can happen gradually.You may begin feeling more tired than usual. You might become impatient over small things or have difficulty sleeping because your mind won't shut off.You may stop exercising, seeing friends or doing activities you once enjoyed because there simply isn't enough time.Some caregivers begin feeling resentful and then immediately feel guilty for feeling that way.These emotions don't mean you don't love the person you're caring for.They may simply mean you need support, too.What Is Respite Care?Respite care provides temporary assistance for an older adult so the primary family caregiver can step away for a period of time.That break might be used to go to work, attend an appointment, spend time with friends, exercise, run errands or simply rest.For some families, respite care may mean having professional assistance for a few hours each week.For others, it may be used occasionally when the regular caregiver has another commitment or simply needs some time away.The purpose is simple:Give family caregivers time to recharge while knowing their loved one is receiving compassionate care at home.Taking a Break Is Part of a Sustainable Care PlanFamily caregivers sometimes feel guilty about asking for help.They may think:"I should be able to handle this."Or:"Mom doesn't want anyone else helping her."But caregiving shouldn't depend on one person doing everything indefinitely.Think about it another way.If you become exhausted, overwhelmed or ill, who will provide the care?Building additional support into the plan can help make caregiving more sustainable over the long term.It also gives the older adult an opportunity to develop a relationship with another trusted caregiver before an emergency occurs.Respite Care Can Benefit the Older Adult, TooRespite care isn't only about helping the family caregiver.It can also be good for the person receiving care.A Comfort Keepers caregiver can provide companionship and conversation while assisting with everyday activities such as meal preparation, light housekeeping, personal care and transportation.Depending on the individual's interests and abilities, the visit might also include taking a walk, playing cards, working on a puzzle, listening to music or simply enjoying a cup of coffee and conversation.This fits naturally with Comfort Keepers' Interactive Caregiving philosophy encouraging older adults to remain involved and engaged in everyday life.Instead of simply having someone "watch" Mom or Dad, respite care can become another source of companionship and meaningful interaction.Start Before You're Completely ExhaustedFamilies often wait too long to ask for help.They wait until the caregiver is overwhelmed.Or until Mom falls.Or Dad is hospitalized.Or someone simply can't keep up anymore.But home care doesn't have to begin with a crisis.Introducing a caregiver earlier can make the transition easier for everyone.Perhaps start with a few hours while the family caregiver runs errands or attends an appointment.Over time, the older adult may begin looking forward to the caregiver's visits.And the family caregiver may discover something equally important:It's okay to step away.Use Your Break for Something That Restores YouIf you arrange respite care, try not to fill every minute with more responsibilities.Yes, there will always be errands.But sometimes the best use of a break is something simple.Have lunch with a friend.Take a walk.Read a book.Go to your own medical appointment.Spend time with your spouse.Play with your grandchildren.Or take an afternoon nap without worrying that someone needs you.Caregivers need opportunities to simply be themselves again.You Can Still Be the Caregiver Without Doing EverythingBringing professional home care into the picture doesn't replace the family.It supports the family.You still know your parent's history, personality, preferences and routines better than anyone.You are still the daughter, son, spouse or trusted family member.But you don't necessarily have to be the cook, driver, housekeeper, companion and caregiver every hour of every day.Sometimes accepting help allows families to reclaim something caregiving can unintentionally take away:the relationship itself.Instead of spending every visit working through a list of chores, you may once again have time to simply sit with Mom.Talk with Dad.Look through photographs.Share a meal.Laugh together.And simply be family.Caring for the Caregiver MattersGood caregiving isn't measured by how much one person can handle alone.It's about creating a support system that works for both the older adult and the people who love them.Comfort Keepers serving Osseo and surrounding Twin Cities communities provides personalized in-home care and respite support that can give family caregivers time to rest and recharge while their loved one receives compassionate assistance at home.Because sometimes the best way to continue caring for someone else is to make sure you're caring for yourself, too.Learn more about Comfort Keepers and additional Minnesota senior resources through Seniors Blue Book, or call Comfort Keepers at 763-273-4207.  

More Than Care: Creating Brighter Days at Home

Discover how Comfort Keepers' Interactive Caregiving approach helps Minnesota seniors stay active, engaged and independent while aging at home.When families first begin looking into home care for an aging parent, they often think about the practical things.Who can help Mom prepare lunch? Who can drive Dad to an appointment? Who can help with laundry, grocery shopping or the everyday tasks that are becoming more difficult?Those things matter. But good home care can be about much more than completing a list of chores.For older adults, the way help is provided can make an enormous difference.Having someone prepare a meal is helpful. Preparing that meal together, talking about a favorite recipe and sitting down to enjoy it together can turn an ordinary task into a meaningful part of the day.That idea is at the heart of Comfort Keepers' approach to in-home care.Doing With, Not Just Doing ForComfort Keepers calls its approach Interactive Caregiving.The philosophy is simple: whenever possible, caregivers do things with older adults rather than simply doing everything for them.Why does that matter?Because independence isn't only about whether someone can live alone. It is also about continuing to make choices, participate in everyday life and feel a sense of purpose.Imagine an older adult who has always enjoyed cooking but can no longer safely prepare an entire meal alone.A caregiver could simply make dinner.Or the caregiver could invite that person to choose the recipe, wash vegetables, stir ingredients, set the table or share stories about meals they used to make for their family.The task gets accomplished either way.But the experience is completely different.Everyday Activities Can Have MeaningSome of the best moments don't require elaborate activities.They happen during ordinary days.Folding towels together can spark a conversation.Looking through an old photo album can bring back wonderful memories.A trip to the grocery store can provide exercise, social interaction and a chance to get out of the house.Listening to favorite music can brighten an afternoon.Working on a puzzle, taking a short walk or watering plants can provide stimulation and a sense of accomplishment.For many older adults, these seemingly small moments help create structure and purpose in the day.That's particularly important for someone who may no longer drive, work, attend as many social activities or see friends as frequently as they once did.Companionship Is Part of CareLoneliness can sometimes develop quietly.An older adult may still be living successfully at home, but the days can become increasingly isolated.Friends move away. A spouse may have passed away. Driving becomes difficult. Winter weather in Minnesota can make getting out even harder.Eventually, someone who once had a busy social life may spend much of the day alone.Companion care can help provide something families sometimes underestimate: regular human connection.Comfort Keepers caregivers can spend time talking with clients, sharing meals, playing games, listening to music, taking walks and helping seniors remain involved in activities they enjoy. The Osseo Comfort Keepers office also provides assistance with errands and transportation to appointments and social activities.Sometimes the most important part of a caregiver's visit isn't what gets checked off a list.It's the conversation that happens along the way.Maintaining Routines Can Help Preserve IndependenceMost of us have routines that make our days feel normal.We drink coffee in a favorite chair.We read the newspaper in the morning.We feed the dog at a certain time.We go to the same grocery store or attend the same church.As people age, maintaining familiar routines can become increasingly important.Home care can provide enough assistance to help older adults continue those routines rather than giving them up simply because certain parts have become difficult.For example, someone who no longer feels comfortable driving doesn't necessarily have to stop meeting a friend for lunch.Someone who needs help walking doesn't necessarily have to stop enjoying the backyard.Someone who struggles with meal preparation doesn't have to give up favorite foods.The right assistance can help bridge the gap between "I can't do that anymore" and "I can still do this with a little help."Personalized Care MattersNo two older adults are exactly alike.One person may love conversation and outings. Another may prefer gardening, music or quiet afternoons doing puzzles.Some people need help primarily with companionship and household tasks. Others may also need personal care, mobility assistance or more frequent support.That's why effective home care should never feel one-size-fits-all.Comfort Keepers develops individualized care plans around each client's needs and can provide services ranging from companionship and meal preparation to transportation, personal care, respite care and more extensive assistance.The goal is to provide the right amount of help while encouraging the older adult to remain involved in their own life.Families Benefit From the Relationship, TooAdult children often carry a tremendous amount of responsibility.They may be coordinating appointments, shopping for groceries, checking medications, helping around the house and calling several times a day to make sure everything is okay.And they're doing all of this while managing their own jobs, children, spouses and responsibilities.Professional home care can provide another trusted person in the older adult's life.That support can give family members greater peace of mind while also allowing their time together to feel more like family time again.Instead of every visit revolving around chores, there may be more time to simply sit down, talk and enjoy one another.Creating Brighter Days at HomeAging at home successfully isn't just about being safe.Quality of life matters, too.It means continuing to laugh.Continuing to participate.Continuing to make choices.Continuing to enjoy favorite activities.And continuing to feel like yourself.Sometimes, a little assistance is what makes those things possible.Comfort Keepers of Osseo serves older adults and families throughout Osseo, Maple Grove, Plymouth, Brooklyn Park and surrounding Minnesota communities with personalized in-home care designed to support independence, engagement and meaningful everyday moments.Because at its best, home care isn't simply about helping someone get through the day.It's about helping make the day worth looking forward to.Learn more about Comfort Keepers and find additional Minnesota senior resources through Seniors Blue Book or call us at 763-273-4207.  

When Is It Time to Consider In-Home Care for a Parent?

Learn the warning signs that an aging parent may need in-home care and how the right support can help Minnesota seniors remain independent.One of the hardest questions adult children face is knowing when an aging parent may need a little more help at home.  The changes are not always dramatic. In fact, they often happen so gradually that families don't notice them right away.Maybe Mom's refrigerator isn't as well stocked as it used to be. Dad has stopped going out as often. There are unopened bills sitting on the counter, laundry is beginning to pile up, or a parent who once took great pride in their appearance isn't getting dressed every day.  Individually, these things may not seem alarming. But together, they can be signs that everyday life is becoming more difficult.  The good news is that needing help doesn't automatically mean leaving home.With the right support, many older adults can continue living safely and independently in the home they love.Look for Changes in Everyday RoutinesWhen you visit a parent, pay attention to what has changed rather than expecting one obvious warning sign.  Start in the kitchen.  Is there fresh food available? Are there expired items in the refrigerator? Has your parent lost weight? Are they relying more heavily on snacks or frozen meals because cooking has become difficult?  Nutrition can be one of the first areas affected when an older adult begins struggling with daily activities.Changes in personal appearance can also provide clues. Wearing the same clothing repeatedly, skipping showers, or having difficulty with grooming may indicate that tasks that once seemed simple have become physically tiring or confusing.  The home itself can tell a story, too.  A growing stack of mail, dishes left in the sink, overflowing trash, laundry that isn't being done or rooms that aren't as tidy as usual may mean your parent could use some additional support.Mobility Can Change More Than We RealizeMobility problems can affect nearly every part of an older adult's day.  Something as simple as getting in and out of the shower, carrying laundry, preparing a meal or walking to the mailbox can become difficult when balance, strength or endurance changes.  You may notice your parent holding onto furniture while walking, avoiding stairs, struggling to get out of a chair or becoming reluctant to leave the house.Fear of falling can sometimes lead older adults to limit their activities even before a fall occurs.  That can create another problem: isolation.Pay Attention to Social ChangesHas your parent stopped attending church, meeting friends for lunch, visiting the senior center or participating in activities they once enjoyed?  Sometimes transportation is the issue. Other times, an older adult may simply feel less confident going places alone.  Social connection is an important part of quality of life.  Companionship and transportation assistance can help older adults remain connected to friends, activities and their community while continuing to live at home.Missed Appointments and Forgotten Tasks MatterEveryone forgets something occasionally.  But if missed medical appointments, unpaid bills, forgotten medications or confusion about schedules become more common, it may be time to look more closely at what is happening.  A little assistance with routines and organization can sometimes make an enormous difference.This is also why families shouldn't wait for a crisis before discussing care.Don't Overlook the Family CaregiverSometimes the clearest sign that additional help is needed isn't the older adult.  It's the caregiver.  Adult children and spouses often gradually take on more responsibilities without realizing how much their role has changed.  A quick trip to the grocery store becomes meal preparation. A ride to an appointment becomes managing an entire medical schedule. Weekend visits turn into daily phone calls, household chores and constant worry.Family caregiving can be incredibly meaningful, but it can also become exhausting.  Professional in-home care can complement what family members are already doing.  Instead of replacing family involvement, it can allow family members to spend more time simply being a daughter, son, spouse or grandchild again.Start the Conversation Before There Is a CrisisTalking with a parent about getting help can feel uncomfortable.  Many older adults hear the word "care" and immediately worry that someone is trying to take away their independence.  A different approach can help.  Instead of saying, "You can't do this anymore," try focusing on what your parent wants to continue doing.If staying at home is important to them, the conversation might become:  "What would make it easier for you to keep living here?"  That changes the discussion from losing independence to protecting it.In-Home Care Can Be FlexibleOne common misconception is that home care has to mean someone is in the house all day.  Care can often be customized around the individual's needs.  Comfort Keepers can provide support with companionship, meal preparation, light housekeeping, transportation, personal care and other everyday activities that may have become challenging.For some families, a few hours of assistance can provide meaningful support. Others may need more frequent care as circumstances change.  The important thing is finding the right level of help for the individual.Choosing an In-Home Care ProviderWhen considering care for someone you love, ask questions.  How are caregivers screened? What training do they receive? How is care supervised? How will the care plan be developed? What happens if your parent's needs change?Most importantly, look for a provider that sees the person rather than simply a list of tasks.  Good care should support safety while also helping an older adult continue enjoying the routines, relationships and activities that give life meaning.A Little Help Can Protect a Lot of IndependenceAccepting help does not mean giving up.  Often, it means exactly the opposite.  Recognizing changes early and putting the right support in place can help an older adult remain safer, more connected and more confident at home.If you've begun noticing small changes in your parent, this may be the right time to start a conversation before those small concerns become a crisis.  Comfort Keepers serving Osseo and surrounding Minnesota communities provides personalized in-home care designed to help older adults continue living safely and independently at home.Learn more about Comfort Keepers and senior care resources through Seniors Blue Book.  Call us today at  (763) 273-4207.  

Local Services By This Author

BrightStar Care of Osprey / Nokomis / Palmer Ranch

Non-Medical 674 South Tamiami Trail, Nokomis, Florida, 34275

BrightStar Care of Osprey / Nokomis / Palmer Ranch is dedicated to providing the best in-home care for you or a loved one. We are a Nurse Owned and Family Operated Private Duty Home Care Agency offering Companion Services (meal prep, transportation, light housekeeping), Personal Care (bathing, dressing, transfers), and Skilled Care (assessments, medication management, med box fills). We also provide Medical Staffing. BrightStar Care is Joint Commission Accredited and Awarded Leader in Excellence, Provider of Choice and Employer of Choice 2016 - 2020 by Home Care Pulse. All caregivers are background checked, drug tested, bonded and insured. We are available 24/7...Just a phone call away!

BrightStar Care of Venice

Non-Medical 425 Commercial Court, Venice, Florida, 34292

Dedicated In-Home Care by BrightStar Care of Venice and Port CharlotteBrightStar Care of Venice and Port Charlotte is dedicated to providing the best in-home care for you or a loved one. We are a Nurse Owned and Family Operated Private Duty Home Care Agency, offering a range of services to meet your needs:Companion Services: Meal preparation, transportation, light housekeepingPersonal Care: Bathing, dressing, transfersSkilled Care: Assessments, medication management, med box fillsMedical Staffing: Providing professional healthcare staff for various needsBrightStar Care is Joint Commission Accredited and has been recognized as a Leader in Excellence, Provider of Choice, and Employer of Choice from 2016 to 2020 by Home Care Pulse. All our caregivers are background checked, drug tested, bonded, and insured.We are available 24/7 and just a phone call away, ready to provide reliable and compassionate care whenever you need it.

BrightStar Care of Port Charlotte

Home Health 1777 Tamiami Trail #408, Port Charlotte, Florida, 33948

BrightStar Care of Venice and Port Charlotte is dedicated to providing the best in-home care for you or a loved one. We are a Nurse Owned and Family Operated Private Duty Home Care Agency offering Companion Services (meal prep, transportation, light housekeeping), Personal Care (bathing, dressing, transfers), and Skilled Care (assessments, medication management, med box fills). We also provide Medical Staffing. BrightStar Care is Joint Commission Accredited and Awarded Leader in Excellence, Provider of Choice and Employer of Choice 2016 - 2020 by Home Care Pulse. All caregivers are background checked, drug tested, bonded and insured. We are available 24/7...Just a phone call away!