What is the Difference Between Assisted Living and Nursing Homes?

Author

Five Star- FL

For more information about the author, click to view their website: Five Star Senior Living

Posted on

Aug 28, 2023

Book/Edition

Florida - Southwest

share-this
Share This

It’s natural that as our bodies age, we may need help with more and more day-to-day tasks. Perhaps you’ve noticed this occurring for a loved one—from struggling to put on support hose first thing in the morning to fumbling with medications just before bed. Or maybe you’re the one needing assistance. Either way, you’re wondering whether it’s time for a change: Would life be better in a senior living community? Which kinds offer help with everyday activities?

The good news is that you have many options when it comes to senior living. With locations in 27 states, there’s a good chance there’s a Five Star independent living, assisted living or memory care community near you or your family. Because there are many choices, however, it can be confusing to know how they differ, and which would be best for you or your loved one.

The similarities between assisted living and nursing homes

Both types of senior communities focus on keeping their residents safe, healthy and happy. Both provide support with what are referred to as Activities of Daily Living (ADLs). These include bathing, dressing and personal care. Other similarities include:

  • Medication Management: Medication errors are a leading reason older adults end up in the emergency room. Managing them can be difficult, especially for seniors who take multiple prescriptions daily. Both types of communities can help residents safely manage their medications.
  • Life Enrichment: We know isolation and loneliness put older adults at greater risk for health problems, such as depression, diabetes and high blood pressure. Assisted living communities and nursing care centers offer a variety of life enrichment activities designed to meet residents’ physical, emotional and spiritual needs.
  • Supportive Services: What causes many older adults to make a move to a senior living community of some kind is the need for support with tasks like housekeeping, laundry and transportation. Both types of communities offer these services.
  • Safe Environment: While their physical layouts are very different, assisted living and nursing care centers are both designed with the security of an older adult in mind. From handrails and grab bars to emergency call systems, both include features to help residents stay safe.
  • Well-balanced Meals: Good nutrition is also a focus for both types of communities. Residents benefit from well-balanced meals and nutritious snacks each day. This is a big plus for adults who may be struggling to shop for food and plan and prepare meals at home.

The differences between nursing homes and assisted living

The biggest differences between these two senior living options are the assistive or medical services provided, living arrangements and cost. Compare the two options here:

ASSISTED LIVING VS. NURSING HOME CARE COMPARISON TABLE

Assisted Living

Nursing Homes

How much care do you receive?In assisted living, residents may need some help with transportation, medication management, housekeeping and other specific activities of daily living such as dressing and personal care, but still live independently.Residents in a nursing home require around the clock care and monitoring. They typically live with more complex health care conditions that require the assistance of a skilled nurse or a physical or speech therapist. Some require respiratory care services.
What other services are offered?Residents receive three nutritious meals each day and access to life enrichment programs in an individual or group setting.Residents receive limited recreational activities along with services like meals, laundry and housekeeping.
What is the living situation like?Assisted living communities are designed to feel home-like and residents typically live in their own apartments or suites with private baths and kitchenettes.Nursing homes have more of a clinical environment and residents typically live in a private or semiprivate room that does not include a living room or kitchen. 
How much does it cost?The median cost of assisted living in the United States in 2021 was $4,300 per month, according to Genworth’s most recent Cost of Care Survey.The median monthly cost of nursing homes in the U.S. in 2021 is about $7,908/month for a semi-private room and $9,034/month for a private room, according to Genworth.

Assisted living: Benefits beyond assistance

Most aging adults seeking help with daily living are not at the level of need addressed by nursing care centers. For many, a Five Star assisted living community may be just what is needed. Our communities offer help with housekeeping, maintenance, laundry and transportation but so much more—including restaurant-quality dining and convenient health services as well as games, clubs and other fun social activities. You get just the amount of help you need to live exactly the life you want to live.

How may we assist?

If you’re looking for an assisted living community, find out if there’s a Five Star Senior Living community near you. We’ll be happy to tell you about all the programs and services we offer to make life easier and more enjoyable!

Other Articles You May Like

How to Tour a Senior Living Community: Key Questions to Ask

Choosing the right senior living community is one of the most important decisions families and older adults can make. Whether you're exploring options for yourself or helping a loved one, visiting a community in person provides insight far beyond what a website or brochure can offer.A thoughtful, well-prepared tour helps you evaluate if a community truly feels like homeand whether it meets your physical, emotional, and social needs. At Seniors Blue Book, were here to make that process easier, more transparent, and more empowering.Heres what to know before you tourand the key questions to ask while you're there. Before the Tour: Do Your HomeworkStart by identifying the level of care that may be needed:Independent Living for active seniors seeking a maintenance-free lifestyle and social engagementAssisted Living for those who need help with daily tasks like bathing or medication managementMemory Care for individuals with Alzheimers or other forms of dementiaSkilled Nursing for seniors requiring 24/7 medical support or short-term rehabilitationUse Seniors Blue Book to search communities in your area, compare services, and read reviews before scheduling your visits. During the Tour: What to Look ForObserve:Cleanliness and overall condition of the communityHow staff interact with residents (Are they friendly and respectful?)Residents' mood and engagement in activitiesSafety features: handrails, lighting, emergency call systemsAccessibility: elevators, ramps, transportation services  Top Questions to Ask During Your VisitCare & ServicesWhat types of care are available on-site if needs change?How are care plans created and updated?Is staff available 24/7? What is the nurse-to-resident ratio?Do you offer memory care or skilled nursing if it becomes necessary?Costs & ContractsWhats included in the monthly fee?Are there additional charges for medication management or assistance with daily living?What is the policy on deposits, refunds, or move-outs?Lifestyle & CommunityWhat kinds of activities are offered daily or weekly?Are meals included? Can dietary needs be accommodated?Can residents bring their own furniture or pets?Are there religious services, wellness programs, or group outings?Communication & Family InvolvementHow is information communicated to family members?Can families be involved in care planning?Are there visiting hours or family events? Downloadable Checklist: Take Notes & CompareBring a notebook or use our free Senior Living Tour Comparison Checklist to rate each community on care, amenities, location, staff friendliness, and overall feel. This helps make an objective decision later. Bonus Tip: Ask to Talk to a Current Resident or Family MemberHearing first-hand experiences from someone living in the community can provide valuable perspectiveand peace of mind.  How Seniors Blue Book Can HelpAt Seniors Blue Book, we connect families with trusted, local senior living options, home health providers, elder care services, and moreall in one place. With our free directory and personalized guidance, you can save time, reduce stress, and feel confident every step of the way.Search listings online: seniorsbluebook.comGet a free book: Available at libraries, hospitals, senior centers, and more Tour with ConfidenceTouring a senior living community shouldnt be overwhelmingit should be empowering. With the right questions, a clear plan, and help from trusted resources like Seniors Blue Book, you can make a decision that supports health, happiness, and peace of mind for years to come.Know someone beginning the search for senior care? Share this guide to help them start with clarity and confidence.

Staffing Requirements in Assisted Living

Staffing requirements in Assisted LivingStaffing requirements in assisted living facilities vary based on state regulations, resident needs, and facility size, but there are common standards and roles that most facilities must fulfill. Heres an overview: Core Staffing Requirements (General)Most states mandate a mix of the following positions:1. Administrator/Executive DirectorRequired in all facilities.Must be licensed or certified (requirements vary by state).Oversees daily operations, compliance, staffing, and finances.2. Direct Care Staff (Caregivers/Aides)Assist residents with activities of daily living (ADLs) such as bathing, dressing, eating, and mobility.Must meet minimum training hours (often 4080 hours).Staffing ratios (residents per caregiver) vary widely but typically range from:1:1015 during daytime1:20+ overnight3. Licensed Nurses (LPNs/RNs)Not always required on-site 24/7, but often required on-call.Responsible for medication management, assessments, and health care coordination.Some states require a nurse if the facility provides certain health services.4. Medication Aides/TechniciansAdminister medications under nurse supervision or per state guidelines.Must complete state-approved medication administration training.5. Housekeeping and MaintenanceEnsure facility cleanliness, safety, and order.Not typically subject to state staffing ratios but are essential for resident well-being.6. Food Service StaffPrepare and serve meals based on dietary plans and nutritional guidelines.Some states require a certified dietary manager or licensed dietitian to oversee meal plans. Staffing Ratios (Examples by State)StateMinimum Staffing RequirementCaliforniaNo fixed ratio; must meet sufficient staff to meet resident needsFloridaRequires an administrator, at least one staff per 20 residents during the day, and one awake staff at nightTexasMust have sufficient staff 24/7; no fixed ratiosNew YorkRequires at least one staff per 25 residents during the day, plus a supervisorOregon1 caregiver per 15 residents during the day; 1 per 25 at night (if residents need assistance at night) Training RequirementsMost states require:Initial training (ranging from 20 to 80 hours)Ongoing in-service training (e.g., dementia care, infection control, emergency response)CPR and First Aid certification Important NotesMemory care units often require higher staffing ratios and specialized dementia training.Staffing must be sufficient to provide services in the resident care plan, regardless of fixed ratios.During inspections or audits, under-staffing is a top citation issue.In Florida, assisted living facilities (ALFs) must comply with both statutory and regulatory staffing requirements to ensure resident care and safety. Heres a detailed breakdown: 1. Minimum Weekly Staff HoursPer Florida Administrative Code Rule 59A36.010, ALFs must meet a minimum number of direct care staff hours each week based on total residents (including daycare and respite). Independent living residents receiving no services are excluded. # ResidentsStaff Hours/Week051686152121625253263529436453354655375566541666754577685498869553996++42 hours per week for each additional 20 residents 2. Staff Availability & Ratios24/7 supervision:At least one qualified staff member must be on-site anytime residents are present home.caringdata.com+5casetext.com+5quality.healthfinder.fl.gov+5.For facilities with 17+ residents, one staff member must be awake and present around the clock FirstAid/CPR coverage:At all times, someone on duty must hold a valid First-Aid and CPR certificate (nurse, EMT, or paramedic qualifies) .Responsible staff in absence:If the administrator or manager is absent longer than 48 hours, a written-designated staff member (21+) must oversee facility duties  3. Staff Qualification & TrainingAdministrator oversight:Every ALF must be supervised by a licensed administrator responsible for operations and staff management.Preservice & Core Training:New staff must complete at least 2 hours of orientation before resident interaction.Ongoing training related to job duties and care must meet FAC 59A36.011 requirements. Medication assistance:Staff helping with self-administration of medication require 6 additional training hours, followed by 2 hours annually. Background screening:All employees (including contracted staff) must undergo Level 2 background checks.  4. Documentation & OversightSchedules & recordkeeping:Facilities must maintain written 24hour staffing schedules and time sheets. For facilities with 17+ residents, job descriptions and staff timesheets are mandatory quality.Record retention:Documentation of staffing compliance must be kept for 5 years home.Agency intervention:If the state agency determines care or supervision is inadequate, facilities must immediately increase staffing and submit a corrective plan. SummaryIn short, Florida ALFs mustMeet minimum weekly direct care hours based on census.Maintain 24/7 awake coverage for 17+ residents.Ensure First-Aid/CPR qualified staff are always present.Provide proper training, credentialing, and documentation.Act promptly when regulators identify staffing shortfalls.

What to Look for in Memory Care in Pittsburgh: A Guide for Families Navigating Alzheimers and Dementia Care

Caring for a loved one with Alzheimers or another form of dementia is emotionally and physically demanding. Over 11 million Americans provide unpaid care for someone living with these progressive conditions, often sacrificing their own well-being along the way. If youve reached a point where professional support is needed, exploring memory care in Pittsburgh can be a powerful step toward ensuring your loved ones safety and quality of life.But not all memory care communities are alike. From the atmosphere and staff training to medical oversight and amenities, the right environment can make all the difference in your loved ones day-to-day experience.Heres a practical guide to help you evaluate memory care options in the Pittsburgh area with confidence.Understanding the Role of Memory CareMemory care is a specialized form of assisted living tailored to individuals with Alzheimers, dementia, and other memory-related conditions. These communities provide: 24/7 support from trained caregivers Secure environments to prevent wandering Structured daily routines Activities designed to promote cognitive function and engagement A diagnosis like Alzheimers often requires care beyond what family members can provide alone. Memory care helps bridge the gap with professional, compassionate support.Key Features to Evaluate When Touring Memory Care Communities1. Staff Experience and Dementia-Specific TrainingWhen it comes to Alzheimers and dementia care, the qualifications of the caregiving team matter. Ask: Are team members Certified Dementia Practitioners (CDPs)? What is the staff-to-resident ratio? How long have key staff been with the community? Experienced, consistent caregivers are more likely to build trust with residents and recognize subtle changes in health or behavior. Look for staff who demonstrate both professionalism and empathy.2. Clean, Comfortable, and Secure EnvironmentDoes the space feel calm, clean, and welcoming? Look for communities that offer: Clear walking paths and secured outdoor areas Wayfinding cues and calming design elements Clean dining rooms, cozy lounges, and thoughtfully furnished private rooms During your tour, observe how residents interact with staff and each other. A warm, relaxed atmosphere often signals good care behind the scenes.3. Personalized Care Plans and On-Site Medical SupportMemory care isnt one-size-fits-all. Quality communities take time to understand each residents personal story, preferences, and stage of cognitive decline. Ask: How are care plans created and updated? Is on-site nursing available 24/7? What procedures are in place for medical emergencies? Knowing that your loved ones needs will be met not just today, but as their condition progresses, offers priceless peace of mind.4. Engaging Life Enrichment ProgramsPeople living with Alzheimers and dementia benefit from structured, meaningful activities. Look for programs that include: Music therapy and art projects Sensory activities and memory games Gentle exercise and stretching Spiritual or religious offerings Group meals and special events Engagement promotes connection, reduces agitation, and helps residents maintain a sense of purpose.5. Reputation, Licensing, and TransparencyA facilitys track record speaks volumes. Do your homework: Read recent reviews from families Ask for inspection reports and licenses Schedule an in-person tour (and follow your instincts) In Pennsylvania, assisted living and memory care communities are regulated at the state level. You can check inspection history through the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services.6. Transportation, Dining, and Additional AmenitiesQuality of life goes beyond medical care. Consider: Is transportation provided to doctors appointments or outings? Are meals nutritious, flexible, and tailored to dietary needs? Is there a beauty salon, library, or garden on-site? Little details like choosing mealtimes or enjoying a favorite hobby can make your loved one feel at home.Final Thoughts: Youre Not Alone in This DecisionChoosing a memory care community is a deeply personal journey. Whether your loved one is in the early stages of Alzheimers or has more advanced dementia, the goal is the same: ensuring they are supported, safe, and surrounded by compassionate professionals who understand their unique needs.If you're beginning the search for memory care in Pittsburgh, were here to help. Our memory care and assisted living community is designed to provide peace of mind, connection, and expert support for both residents and the families who love them. Learn more about our memory care services and how we support families facing Alzheimers and dementia care decisions.