What Long-Term Care Looks Like Around the World
Feb 09, 2024
Pennsylvania - Greater Pittsburgh Area
Email US
Click to Email Us
Around the world, wealthy countries are struggling to afford long-term care for rapidly aging populations. Most spend more than the United States through government funding or insurance that individuals are legally required to obtain. Some protect individuals from exhausting all their income or wealth paying for long-term care. But as in the United States, middle-class and affluent individuals in many countries can bear a substantial portion of the costs. Here’s how five other countries pay for long-term care.
Japan
Long-term care insurance is mandatory for Japanese citizens age 40 and over, while in the United States only a small portion of people voluntarily obtain coverage. Half the funding for Japan’s program comes from tax revenues and half from premiums. Older adults contribute 10% to 30% of the cost of services, depending on their income, and insurance picks up the rest. There is a maximum amount people must spend from their income before the insurance covers the remainder of the cost. Workers can also take up to 93 days of paid leave to help relatives with long-term care needs. Japan assigns a care manager to each person using services; each manager oversees about 40 older adults. In 2020, Japan spent 2% of its gross domestic product on long-term care, 67% more than the United States spent that year.
The Netherlands
The Dutch have included long-term care in their universal health care system since 1968. One public insurance program pays for nursing homes and other institutional settings, and another pays for nursing and personal care at home. Enrollment is mandatory. Dutch taxpayers contribute nearly 10% of their income toward insurance premiums, up to a set amount. Out-of-pocket payments amount to about 7% of the cost of institutional care. General taxes pay for a third program in which municipalities provide financial assistance and social support for older people living at home. There is no private long-term care insurance. The Netherlands spent 4.1% of its gross domestic product on long-term care in 2021, more than any other country tracked by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, and four times the amount the United States spent.
Canada
Provinces and territories fund long-term care services through general tax revenue. Money budgeted is not always enough to cover all services, and some localities give priority to those with the greatest needs. The amount of subsidies people can receive, the costs they have to pay out-of-pocket, and the availability of services vary by province and territory, as they do in the United States with state Medicaid programs. The mix of providers also varies regionally: For instance, nursing home care in Quebec is mostly run by a public system while homes in Ontario are mostly for-profit. Notably, Canada’s long-term care system is separate from its national health care system, which pays for hospitals and doctors with no out-of-pocket costs to patients. In 2021, Canada spent 1.8% of its GDP on long-term care, 80% more than the United States spent.
United Kingdom
Local authorities pay for most long-term care through taxes and central government grants. Private providers usually supply services. Government contributions are based on financial need, with copayments usually required. As in the United States, middle-class and wealthy people pay most or all of the costs themselves. Unlike in the United States, the government provides payments directly to lower-income people so they can hire workers to care for them in their homes. The U.K. has also taken steps to shield people from losing all their wealth to pay for long-term care. It subsidizes care for people with savings and property of less than about $30,000, while in the United States most people don’t qualify for Medicaid until they have run through all but $2,000 to $3,000 of their assets. In 2022, the British government proposed extending subsidies to people who have as much as $105,000 of wealth and property, with a lifetime cap of about $100,000 on how much anyone spends on long-term medical care, excluding room and board in a nursing home. But the plan has been postponed until 2025. In 2021, the United Kingdom spent 1.8% of its GDP on long-term care, 80% more than the United States did.
Singapore
Singapore recently instituted a system of mandatory long-term care insurance for those born in 1980 or later. Citizens and permanent residents are automatically enrolled in an insurance plan called CareShield Life starting at age 30. They must pay premiums until they retire or turn 67 (whichever comes later) or are approved to use services. The government subsidizes 20% to 30% of premiums for those who earn around $2,000 a month or less. Monthly payouts start at about $440. Government subsidies for nursing homes and other institutional care can range from 10% to 75%, depending on ability to pay. Those who make more than $2,000 a month receive no subsidies. CareShield is optional for Singaporeans born in 1979 or earlier; they are covered under an older, voluntary plan. Singapore also provides a means-tested monthly cash grant — this year about $290 — to help with caregiving expenses.
Sources: The National Bureau of Economic Research project on international comparisons of long-term care; Kathleen McGarry; The Commonwealth Fund; Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development; government websites.Note: Spending comparisons with the United States are based on the most recent OECD data and include spending from government and compulsory insurance programs as a percent of each country’s gross domestic product, which is the total monetary value of all the finished goods and services produced within a country’s borders. The comparisons cover people of all ages and exclude spending from voluntary insurance plans and out-of-pocket costs. All currency figures are in U.S. dollars.
KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF—an independent source of health policy research, polling, and journalism. Learn more about KFF.
This story also ran in The New York Times. It can be republished for free.
- To view the original version of this article visit kffhealthnews.org/news/article/dying-broke-long-term-care-other-countries/view/republish/
- Seniors Blue Book was not involved in the creation of this content.
Other Articles You May Like
The Proposed HCBS Access Act: Improving Access to Home-Based Care for Seniors
Seniors who require assistance with daily activities and qualify for Medicaid Long-Term Services and Supports often end up on waiting lists to receive home-based care or in community settings. This forces many to live in institutional facilities, isolating them from their communities and incurring significant costs.Benefits of Aging in Place and HCBS ActHowever, the Home and Community-Based Services (HCBS) Access Act, introduced by U.S. Sen. Bob Casey and U.S. Rep. Debbie Dingell, aims to change this by providing better funding and resources for seniors seeking care at home or in their communities. Not only does aging in place offer emotional and physical benefits, but it also saves money.Key Provisions of HCBS Access ActThe HCBS Access Act seeks to provide enhanced Medicaid funding, grant funding for states developing home care capacity, resources to ensure professional caregivers have stable jobs and wages, training for family caregivers, and improved quality evaluation. With the support of sixteen U.S. representatives and advocacy organizations for older adults, this legislation could make a significant change in bridging the gap between institutional and community-based care.Importance of Consulting with an Elder Law AttorneyNavigating Medicaids complex waiver programs can be daunting. Thats why consulting with an elder law attorney, who is well-versed in the subject, can help ease the process. The proposed Better Care Better Jobs Act is looking to provide additional funding to home care workers while also creating new job opportunities in the field. As the demand for long-term care continues to rise alongside life expectancy, this will be a crucial area of focus in the coming years.Investing in Home-Based Care for SeniorsBy investing in home-based care, not only can we support seniors independence and autonomy, but we can also create better job opportunities and support for family caregivers.Advocating for Our SeniorsThe HCBS Access Act and Better Care Better Jobs Act are steps in the right direction and can help improve the lives of senior citizens who need assistance. With adequate funding, training, and resources in place, we can ensure that our seniors have the care they deserve. It is up to us to make sure these initiatives become a reality and that seniors receive the quality care they are entitled toat home or in their communities. We must continue to advocate for our seniors and ensure their needs are met. Many of them have sacrificed for us, and it is time we do the same for them.
Handling Digital Estate Planning | A Wills and Trusts Attorney in Tampa
Most people at some time give thought to estate planning for the future of their assets and loved ones. But in our modern times, your Digital Estate may not get the attention it deserves. Here, a Wills and Trusts Attorney in Tampa from Mortellaro Law discusses handling your Digital Estate Planning in Florida.What is a Digital Estate?We are surrounded by technology and so it is no surprise that most of our financial affairs are handled through digital mediums. All this electronic information stored on your computer, tablet, smartphone, smart watch, and in the cloud is considered a digital asset and as such, part of your digital estate. These assets may or may not have financial value, but they typically have some sort of value to you, and should be accounted for in your complete estate plan.Think of all the electronic assets you possess and use on a regular basis. Make a tally of them by category so it is easier to keep track of them. This is your Digital Estate.Personal Property | Discusses Handling Digital Estate PlanningList all your personal online accounts on social media, email accounts, personal shopping accounts, photo storage accounts, video sharing accounts, and other ways you interact online. Be sure to include all the usernames and passwords for each account.Property with Monetary ValueList here your accounts that actually hold money, like bank accounts, credit accounts, PayPal, Venmo, Wallet, Samsung Pass, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Cash App, loyalty rewards accounts, online betting accounts, and any other programs or apps that can hold or transfer money. This can also include any bitcoin or other cryptocurrency holdings and NFTs. Again, list the usernames and passwords for each account or app.Business-related PropertyDo you operate an online store like eBay, Etsy, Amazon, or others? These accounts are also part of your digital property. Many may hold real assets like intellectual property you have created (eBooks, drawings, photos, music, etc.) and to which you hold the rights. Include any website domains you hold, blog content with original writing, and online video channels where the content is monetized and produces a profit.It is estimated that the average consumer in the US has around 100 or more online accounts with usernames and passwords! And yet, we often underestimate the value of our digital estate.Managing My Digital Estate Planning with a WillA Will and Trusts Attorney in Tampa can explain how a legal will can help you manage your estate, including your digital estate. All your digital assets and the information required to access them should be recorded in your will. Be sure to include instructions for how you wish these assets to be handled, recorded, donated, liquidated, maintained, or otherwise distributed by your executor.Digital assets with monetary value will be of particular importance, as they will form part of your estate that will be subject to probate. If you hold significant digital assets and do not account for them in your estate planning, this can cause serious problems or setbacks during probate. They may cost your loved ones or other beneficiaries tax penalties and delays. They may also be subject to seizure or liquidation to satisfy debts.Managing My Digital Estate Planning with TrustsDigital assets that hold some monetary value may be better managed by placing them in a Florida trust. Different types of trusts exist to hold property and shield it from probate, excessive taxation, exploitation, and loss. By placing assets in a trust, you can direct how they are used and preserved, saving them for your loved ones and protecting them from risk of seizure by creditors or lawsuits.Asset protection trusts are designed to protect even digital assets from excess taxation, misuse, and more. For example, if you own an online store that contains intellectual property for sale (writing or music for download as an example), this can be an ongoing source of income. Placing this digital asset in a trust allows your beneficiary to continue enjoying the profits of this property indefinitely, or however you leave instruction within the trust documentation.Digital assets in trust can also be left to specific beneficiaries who may better appreciate the assets and enjoy benefitting from them, preserving them for the future, and more.Get Help from a Wills and Trusts Attorney in TampaIf this is the first time you have ever considered your digital estate assets, now is the time to review them and compile a comprehensive record for your estate plan. Help from a Wills and Trusts Attorney in Tampa from Mortellaro Law can be invaluable as you seek to protect your digital assets and preserve them for future generations. Contact Mortellaro Law today to schedule an estate planning consultation and review your digital assets.
What Happens to a Bank Account When Someone Dies Without a Will in Florida?
Losing a loved one can be a difficult and painful time for family and friends. There are many things to consider after someone passes away, including what happens to their bank. If someone dies without a will in Florida, their bank account and other assets will be subject to the states intestacy laws.Dying IntestateIntestacy laws dictate how a persons assets will be distributed if they die without a will. In Florida, if someone dies without a will, their assets will be distributed according to these laws. This means that the deceaseds bank account will be distributed to their heirs according to the states laws. It is important to note that if the deceased person had outstanding debts or liabilities, they must be paid before any assets, including funds in a bank account, can be distributed to heirs. If there are insufficient funds in the bank account to pay off the debts, the heirs may not receive any inheritance from the account.Bank Accounts with Named BeneficiariesIf the decedents bank account has named beneficiaries, it will pass directly to those individuals upon the decedents death. This setup allows control of the bank account and its assets to pass directly to the named beneficiaries without waiting for the exhausting probate process to be completed. The named beneficiaries must show a valid ID and the decedents death certificate to the bank. Bank Accounts with No Named BeneficiariesBank accounts with no named beneficiaries must pass through the probate process. Probate is timely and expensive, and when no will is present, the court will appoint an estate administrator to carry out its orders under state law. This often triggers family disputes and other problems because the law seldom distributes assets like bank accounts according to the familys wishes. Jointly Owned AccountsJointly-owned bank accounts in Florida typically pass to the sole ownership of the surviving joint account owner. This is called rights of survivorship. No probate process should be required.Probate AdministrationTo access the funds in a deceased persons bank account, the appointed executor must provide documentation to the bank to prove that the court has appointed them as the estate executor. This documentation may include a death certificate, letters testamentary, and other legal documents. Avoid Burdening Your Loved Ones Create an Estate Plan TodayIf someone dies without a will in Florida, their bank account will be subject to the states intestacy laws. The funds in the account will be distributed to the heirs according to the states laws. This seldom happens according to the decedents or the familys wishes. Complicated family structures and relationships can prolong the probate process while some may contest the courts distributions. A Tampa Probate Attorney from Mortellaro Law is an invaluable resource when faced with controversial beneficiary distributions by the court-appointed administrator of an intestate loved ones estate. We are happy to consult with you and advise you on your rights and possible courses of action. Of course, preventing this scenario and its burden on your loved ones is crucial. Mortellaro Law can help you create a sound estate plan to fulfill your wishes after your death. Asset distribution, including bank accounts, is just one benefit of establishing an estate plan now. Contact us today for a free consultation about estate planning in Florida.